Coney Island Stillwater — Restaurant in Stillwater

Coney Island in Stillwater is an absolute gem for any food enthusiast seeking a delightful culinary experience. From the moment you step in, it's evident that this establishment takes its food seriously. The star of the show, without a doubt, is the chili dog fries. This dish is nothing short of a masterpiece, where the interplay of rich, flavorful chili, impeccably prepared hot dogs, and perfectly crispy fries creates a symphony of tastes that will leave your palate in awe.

What truly distinguishes Coney Island, however, is the remarkable Chef D. His culinary prowess is nothing short of extraordinary. With every dish, you can taste the passion and expertise that goes into its creation. Chef D has a unique ability to infuse classic favorites with a creative twist, elevating familiar flavors to a whole new level. It's a true testament to their artistry in the kitchen.

Whether it's the artful presentation or the explosion of flavors on your palate, Chef D's creations consistently deliver a dining experience that transcends expectations. Each bite is a revelation, a testament to the dedication and skill that goes into every plate that leaves the kitchen. The attention to detail is impeccable, and it's clear that every element of the dish is carefully considered.

A visit to Coney Island promises more than just a meal; it's a memorable journey for your taste buds. After experiencing the culinary magic crafted by Chef D, you'll find yourself yearning for more. This is a place where food isn't just sustenance; it's an experience, a celebration of flavor and creativity. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge in the extraordinary offerings of Coney Island. Your taste buds...

I have very rarely, if ever change a review on here. This place used to be a 5 star bargain right there on Washington. Now it’s nothing but good old fashioned highway robbery. Seriously I think you can eat for cheaper in an airport terminal.

After the remodel the $5/$6 lunch that used to include two coneys, fries, and a drink is somewhere up around $15. The nuke dog that used to be $2.99 is now $9.00 each. We ordered two without buns (allergy), because the prices weren’t shown for it on the menu, so we assumed it would still be like $5 each, and color our shock when $18 worth of terrible hot dog showed up. Maybe $2 worth of food cost went into it. Check out the picture and tell me that’s $18 worth of food? You can pull a ribeye steak for around the same price here in town.

Save your money and go get a Curty. They’re bigger, better, cheaper, and you’ll be happier.

The remodel killed a great thing. It’s been empty every time I’ve gone in over the past year or two. I remember when it was packed at lunch every single day. I guess when the quality went down, they had to jack up prices on the few remaining customers to try to make up for the losses. Not worth it anymore. Probably the last time I’ll eat here.

I can’t wait to see what new restaurant takes over this space in the...

Coney Island in Stillwater, Oklahoma, is an experience not to be missed if you're a fan of classic American fare. As soon as you walk in, you're greeted by the intoxicating aroma of sizzling hot dogs and freshly cooked fries. But what truly sets this place apart is the awesome chef behind the counter, Chef D. Friendly, engaging, and a master of his craft, he elevates the simple act of making Coney dogs into an art form.

The Coney dogs themselves are a masterpiece. The meaty, juicy sausages are perfectly grilled and loaded with a generous layer of chili and toppings, offering a balanced blend of flavors with each bite. The bun, slightly toasted, holds its integrity from the first bite to the last, which is a feat considering the toppings it has to contain.

And let's not forget the fries. Crisp, golden, and cooked to perfection, they make the perfect sidekick to the main attraction. You can tell that quality ingredients are used, and each fry seems to be cooked with as much love and care as the Coney dogs.

All in all, Coney Island offers more than just food; it offers an experience. With its comfortable atmosphere, outstanding food, and exceptional chef, it's a must-visit spot in Stillwater that leaves you planning your next visit before...