Wise Pies — Restaurant in Terre Haute

I give 5 stars because the only way to describe the food is ABSOLUTE QUALITY. Perfectly topped, nice and crisp and the taste is out of this world. The employees are the best I have ever dealt with at a pizza restaurant. Kind, funny and they actually talk to you as if you are a person and not just lost profit if they don’t do the “service robot”: (Welcome to… your order was… your total is… your change is… do you need your receipt… thank you come again. All while glassy eyed)

My wife and I used to consider this our favorite pizza place. It was a little pricier than larger chain pizzas but well worth it. However, our most recent trip a few weeks ago was most assuredly our last. It was already frustrating the south store shut down for a remodel that has spanned at least a year now, but then they raised their prices. It cost me $47 for two pizzas...again, $47. Ridiculous. Then, we get home and it's like they didn't even try to make a good pizza. We had half BBQ chicken and half carnivore (essentially meat lovers). There was barely any noticeable sauce on either side, it was greasy, and when coupled with costing $47 it became one of our worst experiences with any food service...ever. I advise looking to other places like Little Cee's or Giovanni's. Heck, I'll do Papa John's before...

I stumbled upon this place today because I saw signs as we were heading to the 6th St Arts Festival. I am SO GLAD I tried it. NY Style pizza is my absolute favorite and I saw that they served slices, so obviously, it was meant to be. I tried a slice of their WOW and it was absolute perfection! Thin crust and a little crispy on the bottom. Their flavors and ingredients were phenomenal!! Easily THE BEST PIZZA I’ve had in Indiana or Virginia (my two homes as of late)!!! Don’t hesitate to try this place! I can’t wait to go back!! Really nice staff and atmosphere too! They also serve beer, which pairs well, so I’ll need to get one...