Capone's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta — Restaurant in Toms River

A Hidden Gem That Feels Like Home

Tucked away in the neighborhood, this Italian pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a slice—it’s a true hidden gem that delivers heart, soul, and exceptional hospitality. While the pizza is every bit as delicious as you'd hope—crispy, flavorful, and clearly crafted with care—the real surprise lies in everything else they offer. From fresh pasta dishes to seasonal specials, each meal feels homemade and thoughtfully prepared.

What truly sets this place apart, though, is the owner. From the moment I walked in, I was made to feel genuinely welcome. They go out of their way to accommodate my dietary needs without ever making it feel like an inconvenience. Dining here feels less like visiting a restaurant and more like being a guest at someone’s home.

If you're looking for authentic Italian food with a personal touch, this spot is a must-visit. It’s one of those rare places that manages to be both comforting and a little bit magical. I always leave feeling full—of good food and even...

Pizza and wings were extremely good, a little pricey but you get what you pay for. However the only reason its not 5 stars is because of the delivery driver. This delivery driver drives a grey/silver dodge avenger so beware of him. I forgot to include a tip, which I own up to it and tried to fix , i always tip when i order delivery, but the fact that he gave such a nasty attitude to my younger sister who answered the door when he came back demanding a tip. The second time he came back to my door, he claimed I was $1 short even though I counted the money for the pizzas i ordered. I get it we all make mistakes and have bad days, but to give my sister and myself a nasty attitude when I tried fixing my mistakes is not right. I was calm and nice about it, I did not raise my voice at him either. hopefully the owner sees this and does something about this delivery driver. I do not expect a free meal or drink , however I do expect the owner to do something about this delivery driver, btw I do have it recorded on my Ring...

it was 20 degrees outside and it feels like 10. for lunch my friends and i went to the closest place from the school because it was cold but the closest place we bought food from didn’t have any tables left so we walked to capone’s because it was the next closest place to sit down. my friends and i come to capone’s a lot and buy their food. when we sat down (the whole back room of tables were open) a lady came back and started telling my friends and i that we had to leave if we didn’t buy their food because it “wasn’t fair to them” this would be totally understandable if there wasn’t a lot of available space left for customers. but that wasn’t the case. i find it rude that we are students from the high school and give them business practically everyday. i spend $25 in capone’s every week. so i had to buy food just so my friends and i can avoid walking to main street in the freezing cold (with the lunch period being so short we probably wouldn’t even have time to...