Bellagio Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

Bellagio Pizzeria is a husband-and-wife-owned treasure that brings warmth, authenticity, and bold flavor to every dish they serve. What sets this spot apart isn't just the amazing food—it’s the fact that every item is halal, a rare find when it comes to such classic Italian-American comfort dishes.

We ordered a pizza pie split between buffalo chicken and pepperoni—each half was packed with flavor and perfectly baked. The crust had the right crunch, and the toppings were generous and fresh.

The Penne alla Vodka with crispy chicken was creamy, rich, and comforting, while the Rigatoni Florentine with charred grilled chicken delivered a beautiful balance of smokiness and savory sauce. Every bite felt carefully crafted.

But the star for us might’ve been the Meatball Parm on garlic bread. Hearty, flavorful meatballs smothered in sauce and cheese, nestled in garlicky, toasty bread—it was indulgent in the best way.

Bellagio Pizzeria isn’t just serving halal food—it’s delivering top-tier flavor that rivals (or beats) the usual favorites, with the added comfort of knowing everything is halal. A must-try spot whether you're local or just...

Unbelievable. I love, love, LOVE this new & improved Bellagios!!!!! Charming & comfortable atmosphere; feels like small town Italy! Even met the owners (Isabelle & Joel). What a lovely & personable couple. They are completely dedicated to providing first class service. They shared how they want to bring Italian quality to Long Island, so they have personal experience/research & awareness into providing the very best ingredients, which shows cause the food is absolutely amazing!! They don’t cut corners with subpar ingredients & are hyper-conscientious with quality. I am a nurse and during our conversation, Isabelle told me she is an open heart nurse!! What an additional impressive skill to have on hand: being served the very best Italian food from a cardiac nurse who’s able to save your life! lol Obviously they are worldly, intelligent and compassionate - and it shows!!!! I recently had them cater my son’s graduation party and everyone was beyond impressed!!! Thank you Isabelle & Joel! I’m sooooo happy you’re in our community. You have forever customers with me and my family & I will forever refer you business! XO Love your...

Farmingdale is a great town, but is severely lacking in the quality pizza department. This is definitely one of the better places, as I’ve been there twice since they’ve moved to their new location. It seems like they still have some kinks to iron out, like the Talluci’s website and google listing still being live, and they are even using Talluci bags. They also seem to have issues with their online ordering system and probably need to check their oven temps, because the three pizzas I’ve had were way too floppy. All this I can forgive as growing pains of a new location. What I can’t forgive, and have to dock a star for, are these “garlic” knots. I don’t know how they can proudly serve them, because they are basically just buttered rolls. You have to toss them in…garlic, and ideally cheese and parsley. Otherwise they are just...