Deer Park Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

(Latest review) Having recently tried some other pizza places, I still believe that Deer Park Pizza is worth the money, but now I feel it is pricy. They make a great pizza, and they are my preferred pizza delivery provider, but their prices have increased significantly during the past year or so, to the point where I would say that they are expensive but worth it if you want the best. (Older portion of review) Deer Park Pizza makes a delicious pizza loaded with the toppings you request. They deliver the pie quickly and “hot”, and at a fair price. While I find the pie to be the perfect size for my wife and I, I should note that their large pie is 16 inches in diameter, while many I have ordered elsewhere have been about 18 inches (check it out…large pie sizes vary tremendously). (Note that prices have gone up a lot recently, so the following pricing is old information, but the scaling still works). My 16-inch pie with 3 different toppings costing $27 would be about $34 if 18 inches (using good old pi(e) * radius squared). Of course, that would only be true if those larger pies were as generous with their toppings as Deer Park Pizza, and I have found that they are not. Nor do they have that great flavor. Thus, it is cheaper than many pies and great if that is the right size for you, but either way you are getting quality all the way around...

I just got off the phone with, I'm assuming one of the employee's I had this problem once before with everyone charging a surcharge on a debit card which is the same as cash it is ILLEGAL to do this! Now, I'm not blaming him but he said they've been doing it for years. That doesn't mean it's LEGAL! If he's been doing it for years it just means they got away with it because they don't know the law! However, he didn't get away with me, because come Monday morning August 4th, I'm calling the Federal Trade Commission and reporting him! I've already reported PINO'S Pizza 3 years ago and he received a fine and I got all my money backfrom the entire sale! They try to pull that stunt these crooks! You CANNOT do this it's illegal! You can only charge a surcharge on "Credit Cards" NOT a "Debit Card." A Debit Card is the same as CASH it's NOT a Credit Card! Expect a visit from an...

Fast, easy service. Every time I want pizza, they're my go-to place! Good quality food at a VERY REASONABLE price. They offer good deals and they're really friendly there.

Anyone that says the customer service was bad is obviously lying because going here for 3+ years, I've been treated with respect and so has every other customer I've seen.

As far as food, I only get their pizza, garlic knots, and zeppolies, so I can only really tell you about that if you have any questions. The pizza crust is the right thickness, the garlic knots are fluffy and flavorful (although it was once where they were a little overdone, but everybody has a preference), and the zeppolies come with a whole lot of...