Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Babylon

Been going to Mama Sbarro’s forever and now using them to Carter all Events at the Knights. We receive nothing but amazing Compliments all the time.

What sets this local pizzeria apart is not only the exceptional quality of their dishes but also their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction. The flavors are vibrant, the ingredients fresh, you can taste the freshness in every bite, making each dish delicious.

Whether you're planning a special event, a corporate gathering, or simply a casual get-together with friends, Mama Sbarro's in Deer Park catering menu is sure to impress. I highly recommend trying their Penne Alla Vodka, Lobster Ravioli, Orecchiette with Sausage & Broccoli Rabe, Filet of Sole Oreganata dishes for a truly unforgettable dining experience that will have your guests raving and these are only a few of our favorite.

But it's not just the food that makes Mama Sbarro a standout dining destination. The manager, Nicole, is truly incredible. Her warm hospitality and attention to all your needs create a welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere. Her passion for ensuring that every guest has a memorable dining experience shines through in every interaction.

Furthermore, the staff at Mama Sbarro is incredibly nice, adding to the overall welcoming ambiance of the restaurant. From the servers to the kitchen staff, everyone goes above and beyond to make diners feel at home. Additionally, the delivery drivers are equally considerate and helpful, ensuring that your catering orders or meals arrive promptly and in perfect condition.

Whether you're a regular or trying Mama Sbarro for the first time, you can expect consistently delicious food, excellent service, and a welcoming environment that feels like home. The Knight’s with Nicole's exceptional management, along with the friendly and helpful staff and delivery drivers, make Mama Sbarro Deer Park a must-visit for anyone looking for a truly unforgettable...

It's me Calogero with another review , So Me and my girlfriend went to Went to Sbarro in DeerPark on Rt 231 and had dinner and appetizers here, First we had Stuffed Mushrooms (so good) and also Fried Calamari (excellent) and for dinner I had the Shrimp Scampi (Omg so good) and she had the Lobster Ravioli.( So so good ) and the manager Antonio was so nice he gave us both a complementry glass of wine and the service we got from the server Amanda was incredible she was so sweet. So I am definitely giving this food and service 2 thumbs up and 5 stars. ####################### Ok so I went to Mamma's Brick Oven Pizza because I was craving pizza and when I walked in they have this beautiful display of all these different slices and I couldn't make up my mind so one of the managers Nicole came over and says can I help you cuz you look undecided and I said yeah what could you recommend and she said try the Vodka slice and the spinach slice and I got to tell you that was a great recommendation because they were both to die for and she was so sweet she offered another recommendation which was the Sicilian slice and oh my God that was fantastic and I got to tell you I could have eaten one of every slice in the display case because everything looks so delicious and everybody so nice in this restaurant Pizzeria is incredible I give it 2thumbs up and 5 stars once again (oh...and the slices are huge) and today's date is...

I used to really enjoy this place until the decline over the past several months. I've been frequenting this place for many many years through many different owners and sadly this is the worst it's ever been. The cooks are inconsistent, the pizza is vastly different from day to day, each cook has their own way of prepping the pizza, sometimes it's flat out horrible and other times good. A big problem I've been encountering is the cooks do not keep the house pies stocked adequately, more often then not as of late, I come in and the slice I want isn't out and I'm asked to wait 20 minutes, walk-ins don't have time for that. Today I'm told there are no chicken marsala slices, I ask if they have any coming out, the answer I got was that nobody prepared the chicken marsala the day before so there are no chicken marsala pies today. Its just one thing after the other. Sad that such a good place has taken such a dive. The counter girls and wait staff are very nice and helpful, I would give them 5 stars, everything else gets 1 star at this point....the point of...