Oriental Sushi — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Jimmy the owner has been in the area for a long time now, I have knewn him since he was in Huntington over 15 years ago at a dim sum house called ESG. His sushi is the best all you can eat sushi in NY hands down. His sushi is always fresh and if you like sushi especially the fish on rice (nigiri) you will love it. The atmosphere is lack luster and if you want water or tea you get it yourself but forget appearances if you want good food. Definately not a first date place unless you are serious sushi fans hence the 4 stars. Always anywhere you go never eat the white tuna because it is 99% of the time Escolar (Google it) unless you are having a $100 per person sushi Manhattan restaurant. Otherwise dont eat it. Everything else is awesome and don't eat red snapper sushi at anyplace either because usually it is mislabeled it is an industry problem. But again jimmies sushi 1/2 price sushi aka oriental sushi is the best. Try the shrimp tempura hand roll. And expect for him to possibly come out and personally give you some fried white fish with eel sauce and some edamame on the house....

Food was good and tastes fresh. Had one bad roll that tasted like cat food but that's more on me for ordering it. HOWEVER SERVICE WAS AWFUL. Not many people in when we arrived and wait about 30-45 minutes to get out rolls. Asked for water (our mistake) waited the 30-45 minutes before we just decided to get up and were forced to buy drinks and then magically the water appeared(basically don't expect to get a drink unless you laying out $$). Also if you leave even one piece of sushi on your plate they charge you granted only 50¢ but it's excessive. The running joke the whole meal became "oh if your getting up for the bathroom that's an extra dollar".

That being said we all went in with the intention of getting the all you can eat for 18.99 and because it took so long non of us ordered seconds, they did do right by us and adjusted the price (because some of us got basic rolls and didn't even meet the 18.99 bracket ). All in all the food wasn't bad, but the only reason they have good prices is because the buckle and dime...

The best balance of price and quality. Their all-you-can-eat menu has some great options like the Spicy Girl Roll and Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese. I also love their mackerel and tuna sushi. Not everything on the menu is a winner -- the all-you-can-eat menu has way too many shrimp tempura special rolls, for example -- but the big deal here is that you can eat good quality sushi and it doesn't have to be a special occasion because the prices are fair.

Lastly, a lot of people worry about sushi places making them sick and I can say out of any sushi place on LI I've put this place to the test. I've been here dozens of times and the only sick I get is from eating too much good sushi!

Oh and one last thing! Bring cash and your own drink! They have Snapple and tea and bottled water, but they're pretty bare bones as far as drinks go. They're totally cool with you bringing whatever drink you want though -- I've even seen some people with...