Jimmy John's — Restaurant in Town of Hempstead

This Jimmy Johns is located inside a Dukin Donuts which shares the space with them. They have a fountain for sodas and a stand for chips while the rest of the store is dominated by Donkun Donuts.

This is my first time eating their food and I was hungry, not certain if I'd go to Popeyes or McDonalds. When I saw JJ, I decided to give them a try.

I ordered the GARGANTUAN for $15 which would fill my desire to have a sub sandwich, Italian style.

For the most part, the sandwich was stuffed with meat and definitely more filling than Subways. At first I was worried I wouldn't get a lot for my money because the roll looked shorter than 1 foot, but it ended up being quite filling. The only thing that annoyed me was the meat and bread felt "slimy" which was probably due to oil/grease covering it. The meat was fresh.

The subs we order for Super Bowl or special occasions are usually dry and that makes them better to handle I feel.

The food is good and I'd...

Similar to the other two Jimmy John’s recently opened on Long Island:

Dirtier than the typical Jimmy John’s (floors, tables, walls). Shares a space with Dunkin Good music, but no Jimmy’s signs or quotes

Things feel a little off in these three new Dunkin/Jimmy John’s locations. The off thing at this visit was very thickly cut ham on the sandwich.

No deal breakers, but if this place (and the 2 other locations): (1) performed a deep clean asap (2) scheduled more regular cleanings throughout the day (3) revisited quality and consistency (there is something a little off here.. maybe it is the dirty atmosphere that makes the food taste a little off?) (4) get the Jimmy’s signs and quotes up on the wall.

It’s a shame, Jimmy’s is my favorite restaurant, and every other one I have visited across the country has had consistent cleanliness and quality. These three new locations are outliers. I hope they can adjust and save the...

This location is housed along with a Dunkin, as has been mentioned in other reviews. However, it seems to be chronically understaffed. Today I went in to pick up an online order, and there was only one person working in the entire place! She had a great attitude and was doing a solid job; my order came out exactly as I placed it which was impressive considering the 7+ customers waiting. I personally watched two people leave because of the wait. The quality of the food was fine and what I expect from Jimmy John’s.

I really hope the management reads this and improves their staffing - and please hire more people like Favor! She was a rock star in the...