Jeff's Gourmet Market — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

I have been shopping at Jeff's for close to 20 years. I have always been very happy with every purchase and willing to pay their high prices. However, last week's purchase needs to be made public. I purchased a pint of crab and corn chowder and a pint of manhattan clam chowder at $8 each. The clam chowder was nothing more than thin, watery, tomato broth. There were hardly any vegetables or potatoes in the pint. The kicker was that there was ONE tiny piece of clam in the pint. The crab and corn chowder was spoiled. My first hint that something was wrong was the bulging lid. When I took the lid off, a sour odor came out. I took one tiny taste and spit it out.

Jeff's soups have always been good. But, be aware that either their standard has been markedly lowered or I just had bad luck....

I visited the new location tonight. It was clean big selection of fish, crab cakes, oysters, clams, soups and the location has a grill with hot food, boars head cold cuts, grilled chicken, meats, salads and fresh variety of steaks for the grill..Many Peter Luger products as well. I saw fresh Italian bread, fresh raviolis and many sauces..Italian specialties. Super impressed they also share the space with “Roots” formerly from the village for great smoothies acai bowls. My flounder filets were delicious and at a fair price..less than other surrounding places..I will continue returning Jeff’s is the best place for fresh seafood...

More of a suggestion than review. Old Jefffs used inside out plastic bag as glove. Went there on Mothers Day and the gentleman behind the fish counter is wearing gloves handling the fish and plastic bag and then hands me a bag of fish with his fishy gloves that I now have to handle. Bit of a germaphobe so I take notice that my hands are now covered with fish slime from the bag that I have to carry to the register at which time it’s placed into a paper bag.Lots of cross contamination going on.Prefer the old way of...