Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Honestly, one of the worst burgers I've ever eaten in my life.... We went for a band. Ordered beers and the first 2 were completely flat, but they tapped a new keg and made up for that so that is fine. The pretzel app was ok but they ran out of cheese and didn't tell us until the pretzel was already out. Wings were bland, slightly overcooked and half didnt even have sauce on them. The fried pickles were the only good item from the whole night. Fish and chips were basically tasteless and the fries were cold. The burger was ordered as super rare, but what was delivered was a bland beyond well done hockey puck with basically 1 slice of the little cherry tomatoes. I can without question say that I had a better at the food court of the bronx zoo. We went as a family of 6 and literally every single person threw half of their meal away because it was that bad. We would have said something about the food but after it was delivered we never saw the waitress again until we finally got tired of waiting and tracked them down to just pay and get out of the place. Without a doubt, one of, if not the worst meal I have ever had to dish out $175 to pay for. Not to mention the fact that when the food came out, they spilt coleslaw on me and just completely ignored it. I honestly don't understand where these good reviews are coming from. I assuming it's a bunch of regulars or staff? As mentioned, without question, the worst meal I have ever had at any eating...

EVERYTHING we ordered was horrible, I don’t know where to start. The buffalo wrap was completely inedible because of how salty it was. Upon closer inspection I realized it was mostly just blue cheese and sauce with very little chicken and no lettuce or tomato to cut it. The chicken tenders were way overpriced for three hard, thin strips. The shepards pie was dry and flavorless. I never thought I would describe shepards pie as dry, but here we are. I mean, at least add a packet of store bought gravy. The worst offender was the irish stew. It was literally gray mush. I honestly thought I was given the wrong dish at first but then realized that the color was due to the fact that it was probably old and reheated numerous times. My dog’s Merrick wet food looks so much more appetizing. I’m hoping my dog won’t find the stew repugnant so that I can at least have someone eat it. The only dish we were able to finish was the potato soup. But that doesn’t mean it was delicious. It tasted like a potato. That’s it. Just like a potato with no seasoning or toppings. $67 later and we were left eating...

Still chasing the elusively authentic Shepherds Pie and once again, it’s a no-go! But Karen, the bartender, was great and quite instrumental in getting me another Pie. Here, they serve the dish with a gravy over the mashed potatoes—and it was excruciating salty! Just with one little piece, my tongue was burning. The second pie, was much better, but compared to all my other Shepherds Pies, it did not measure up. First, it was unconstructed at the bottom, and the ground beef did not get the attention it deserved. More attention went into the Guinness-based gravy then preparing the ground beef. Yet, not only the gravy was too salty, it tasted like it came from a jar, ugh. Also to be noted, the top layer of mashed potatoes did not do justice to the failing dish. It has always been my firm belief, every Irish & British eatery should have at least one signature dish. A giant pretzel is way too...