Renzo's — Restaurant in Town of Islip

The two guys working on Monday 7/29 should not be working together. I had to repeat my order 4x on the phone, for them to still forget things. Then when I went back for it, they insisted I didn’t pay. Thankfully one of the girls was there eating with her family and pulled the invoice to show them they were wrong. Then I get home and do the math and realized they charged me double for one of the pasta dishes. Very turned off by this place lately and this was the icing on the cake. If you are ordering make sure you’re speaking to one of owners or his daughters- if someone...

We love renzos! The people are amazing there is always something awesome to try. They are always trying new combos along with the classics. The best specialty slices are penne ala vodka, white with broccoli, eggplant parmesan and buffalo chicken with a side of ranch!! They also have this roll thing if you can get one they only make a few a day it's grilled chicken lettuce onion or no onion a combo of fresh mozzarella and shredded mozzarella with a ceasar dressing rolled up in thin pizza dough! It is to die for! I pass at least six other pizza places to go here....

Been going to Renzo's since I was a kid. Went last week for an eggplant slice which imo was the best I’ve had anywhere and was very dissapointed. Apparently they are under new ownership and as some things may be the same they put all the specialty slices on a deep dish and it is terrible. If you are going to keep the brand then keep it to its fullest. Otherwise change the name. Plain slice was good staff was the same and extremely friendly as always. They also offer a reward program which is cool. Hopefully they go back to the old recipes or just...