Pickled Pig Deli — Restaurant in Town of New Paltz

As someone who grew up and always lived in New Paltz, I’ve always been a big fan of Russo’s.

I do want to make it clear that this place is NOT Russo’s, and never will replace or beat Russo’s. NEVER!!

However, the Pickled Pig is a wonderful deli, of exceptional standards, quality, and service.

For starters, their hours are AMAZING! Open 7 days a week, and early. And they’re super reliable. Great place to get breakfast on the run. Or lunch if you’re in a time crunch.

The time it takes to get your meal is also very quick. That however, does not bring down the quality. Everything is made fresh, especially all the chicken cutlets are fried to order. It’s actually really good.

Another thing I’d like to point out is that the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the quality. Better bring cash though, cause it’s a little bit more if you pay via card.

I’ve personally found myself become a regular customer, going there multiple times a week for breakfast and lunch. It’s the combination of quality, convenience, and pricing. Totally worth it.

Thanks a lot Pickled Pig, really grateful to have you...

The Pickled Pig Deli in New Paltz is the epitome of a downgrade. Gone are the days of homemade focaccia, olive tapenade, and calzones that could make your nonna weep with joy. Instead? Brace yourself: the “menu” now reads like a sad convenience store deli counter—bologna, roast beef, and ham, all presented as if they’re some groundbreaking culinary masterpieces. And don’t even get me started on their so-called “specialty” sandwiches—basically breaded chicken thrown into every tired variation possible. Truly inspiring (eye roll).

It’s like the new owners looked at a thriving, beloved spot and thought, “You know what? Let’s just gut everything good and replace it with mediocrity.” Rather than evolving what made the original place so iconic, they decided to strip it of its charm and identity. The warmth, the flavor, the soul? Gone. Instead, we’re left with a husk of what used to be—just another soulless deli with zero passion. Heartbreaking doesn’t even begin...

I haven’t reviewed a restaurant in a while, but this one deserves it. I’m a 2020 SUNY New Paltz graduate so I’ve had my fair share of Russo’s Deli. When I heard they got bought out I was very skeptical about going on my visit back to New Paltz. A few reviews about how it was a downgrade from Russo’s stood out. However, the record needs to be set straight. While this place is not Russo’s, and I do miss the homemade focaccia, Pickled Pig Deli is still an amazing spot and deserves some recognition. The workers (and I think owner?) were all very nice and the food is awesome. I’m especially glad they kept the My Cousin Luca sandwich as I was able to introduce it to my girlfriend after hyping it up so much. It wasn’t Russo’s My Cousin Luca…it was...