Baker Hill Tavern — Restaurant in Town of North Hempstead

After enjoying the Village Green Park Festival, we decided to skip the pricey food vendors and check out Baker Hill Tavern, conveniently located right next to the park. This turned out to be a great choice — not only was it more economical, but the food was fantastic.

⸻

What We Ordered

We went all in and tried a variety of pizzas. For the table, we ordered a full Margherita pie — classic, fresh, and bursting with flavor from the mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil.

We also picked up slices of: • Spicy Buffalo Chicken Pizza – perfectly balanced heat with tender chicken and a drizzle of sauce that made it extra tasty. • Caesar Chicken Pizza – a unique twist with fresh lettuce, creamy dressing, and savory chicken on a crispy base. • Chicken Taco Pizza – a fun fusion of taco flavors with seasoned chicken, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of spice.

⸻

Taste & Quality

Every slice we had was fresh, hot, and full of flavor. The crust was just the right mix of crispy and chewy, and the toppings were generous without overpowering the base. You could tell everything was made with care.

⸻

Overall Experience

Baker Hill Tavern is more than just a convenient stop next to the festival — it’s a spot worth visiting on its own. The service was quick, the staff was friendly, and the quality of the food easily rivaled any pizza place in the area. If you’re in the neighborhood, whether for a community event or just passing through, this is the place to grab a delicious...

The bar has a great old-school vibe with a classic structure that adds a lot of character. It feels like a place with real history, which I genuinely appreciated.

That said, I was pretty surprised—and honestly disappointed—when I saw I was charged $19 for a single Patron on the rocks. I definitely didn’t ask for a double, and at most bars, it’s standard practice to confirm whether the customer wants a single or a double before pouring.

There’s always an excuse, but this just felt like poor transparency and not in line with best bar practices. It really took away from the overall...

If you’re looking for a nice place to unwind after work or catch the games on nights and weekends, I highly recommend Baker hill tavern in great neck NY. Wether you prefer a nice cold beer, or mixed drinks this place has a wide variety of ales and spirits, the staff is extremely friendly, especially Kenny, who has owned the establishment since 2005. We enjoy the bar menu, especially their handmade pizza wich is top notch! The locals are friendly as well and the place is spotless and the staff follows the social distancing and mask rules 100%. I highly...