Souvlaki Place of Bayville — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

I've been coming to this location for many, many years. I have seen the different ownership's as well. The place is now absolutely BEAUTIFUL and can have great potential as long as they keep the quality of the food it serves. It seems you still have the same staff in the kitchen, they've been there too for several years, with the previous owners too! The previous owner that took over started to buy a poor quality feta cheese and I noticed it right away. I mentioned it and it was replaced with a better quality. Your kitchen staff (cooks) have to follow orders from the boss and I guess the norm is to cut back in some of the products and how it's prepared and cooked. I was there a couple of days ago and ordered the Greek salad with grilled chicken. The chicken is not marinated as before and a bit overcooked, therefore, too dry. I ordered a spinach/feta pie to take out. When I went to eat it later at home, it had very little feta cheese. Summer is coming and you'll have a big chance to re-coop all the investment it was made. The chef/cooks, products used can make or brake a restaurant. Good luck to the two young owners and yes, I will...

Thank you very much. I do not know why people say the new owner isn't good. We were visiting NY and this was one of our favorite place to go to....... they did a great job and it was just like I remembered..... food was excellent love my gyro with red sauce. It was just as we remembered..... we were only in NY for 5 days and we made sure we ate there twice. I can't wait to go back for more. The only thing i missed was the pita pocket, i prefer that better then the traditional pita. Great job guys..... thank you for the number for the kima can't wait to call them. Thanks for a memorable experience......

So, this place was a gem and the food was amazing! The woman at the counter was also extremely friendly helpful! I appreciated that! Came here after a day at the Planting Fields Arboretum Park and it made my day until....my girlfriend and I got serious stomach aches from the food. We had the lunch serving and it was a very hefty meal, but something was up. I wouldn't necessarily knock it for that, but 2 for 2 on the stomach pain is a little concerning. Would recommend, I doubt they're in business for as long as they have been if there were any...