Antonella's Pizza Wappingers Falls — Restaurant in Town of Poughkeepsie

We’ve ordered from here regularly since moving to Dutchess nearly 5 years ago after trying many places and found this to be the best pizza in the area. Sadly, it seems that they’ve changed ownership within the past few months and our last two orders were disappointing. A few weeks ago, we were in the mood for a sausage pie and when my husband got home, the pizza was a sloppy mess. The cheese was sliding off all over the place like it should have been cooked more and the presentation of the pizza was awful. If we weren’t so hungry, we would’ve brought it back. Decided to order again tonight and this time we had the opposite problem. I opened the box and said “what the heck?” My husband joked that they confused our order with someone who wanted their pizza extra crispy. The crust was visibly burned in several places and was overcooked this time. I ordered a chicken entrée which no longer comes with a salad. The employee told my husband that they lowered the prices and the salad was an additional charge. The menu that I have at home may be outdated but it shows the same $17.95 for the entrée, including a salad. I don’t care about a salad necessarily and I understand food prices have gone up, but it feels dishonest. I guess our love affair with Antonellas has...

Since I work pretty close by, I always come here to grab a quick something to eat. Every time I come here I’m greeted by the very amazing staff. Jessica is PHENOMENAL! Whenever she’s behind the counter it’s like talking to a friend. She clearly understands what she’s doing and makes you feel as comfortable as possible creating a positive environment which from working in the food industry is very important. She truly feels like the beating heart of the restaurant and it’s always great to see her. As for Chuck and Angelo, those two gentlemen are amazing as well. Recently they really showed how much they value customer satisfaction. I came in and saw that they didn’t have a pizza type I usually get (the penne slices) on display, I was okay with it because I know I’d come back again and it would be there another day. But those 2 gentlemen took the initiative to very kindly ask the staff to make me a slice just so I wouldn’t leave unsatisfied. Seeing how much they all prioritize amazing service is truly admirable. No other local pizzeria has made me feel a comforting ambiance quite as...

Tonight I received the most disgusting pizza I have ever tasted! I hate hate to leave bad reviews, but in this case I have to. Back years ago the pizza was good! sometimes they would burn it, but whatever it happens . I don’t know if they have a new cook or what? Maybe the food was old? All I know is my four year old who loves pizza, and was really looking forward to eating it, and I have never seen him not eat pizza!! .... took one bite then another and said this taste like throw up. So I took a bite.... yup it sure did! I smelled it and it didn’t smell like Pizza, then I notice the cheese was gritty inside. We didn’t have time to take the drive back to complain about the pizza, and I don’t care about getting my money back. What a care about is my son screaming yeah! Yeah pizza! Then telling me it taste like throw up and not being able to eat it! This pizza is going in the garbage right now. My son better not get sick tonight from this pizza! I’m done with this place. I will not recommend...