A Slice of Italy — Restaurant in Town of Ulster

To start, I usually genuinely enjoy this establishments food when I order takeout. It was ordinary Italian-American fare. The people at the takeout counter seemed friendly and genuine. Unfortunately, the dine-in experience was below average and the vibe was generally uncomfortable. The inside was decorated like a nursing homes Rec room. The floor was dirty and the atmosphere was uninviting. I went with a couple family members to have a pizza and relax one evening. We were rushed throughout the entire experience… It took all of 30 mins for us to order and eat then be rushed out the door. The older lady waitressing for our table was quite rude. Every time we said thank you she would not respond and every request we had felt like we were a complete bother to her. She seemed to have an attitude the entire time. The other waitressing staff was the same way. Near the end of our meal the bill was dropped at our table without a word and we got up to pay and leave. I waited nearly 5 minutes after being ignored by the staff. I then proceeded to try to pay at the other counter near the door and they all suddenly noticed and acted like I was trying to dine and dash. The staff was rolling their eyes and whispering to each other while I waited to finally pay, making me feel extremely awkward. I will not be giving any more of my hard earned money to this establishment,...

so glad we found this place. we were camping in peekamoose and stopped by here for food. we came the following morning and they treated us like family. we got the meat pie slice which was a slice of HEAVEN. this must’ve been about 1pm so it was slow but they had plenty of food. loaded with protein, so delicious, melts in your mouth, with a huge bowl of sauce. would drive up from long island 2 hours to eat this again. the staff was kind and generous. i guess the owners, two ppl who worked at the front, told us so many great things about where they lived. they didn’t treat us like outsiders. we told them we were headed to colgate lake and the lady said it was her favorite place on earth. probably mine too haha. they bid us farewell but was such a pleasure to be here and will come again and again. close to woodstock and right off the 87....

I travel for a living and eat at a lot of restaurants. Before coming here, i read the reviews. Most were good, some bad. You are never going to find a place that doesn't have a bad review because some people are never happy. I will say i was happy with A Slice of Italy. The place was very busy for a Tuesday night. It might be because they are supporting a local fundraiser or because the food is good. But a busy restaurant is a good indicator the food is good. And it is. I had fried ravioli as an appetizer knowing my food might take a little while because they were so busy. My entree was meatball parm. Besides it being huge, it was very good. And like i said, they were hosting a local fundraiser. So if you want good food by good people who are local and support their community, then give this place a go. You won't be...