Since moving to Endwell from Binghamton, Sammy’s Ice Cream and Italian Ice has expanded their menu. They now sell baked goods, ex. Brownies, Peanut Butter Cups and Chocolate chunks w/ peanuts. I approached the owner, Lisa Shattuck, about baking a cake for my son’s graduation. I was in a bind because I only had a couple days(2) to get this done. Lisa didn’t hesitate and accepted the job🥰! Yesterday, we picked the cake up and IT’S ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS!! The cake, the decorations, the size and the taste are all PERFECT!! THIS CAKE IS DONE TO/WITH PERFECTION😊!! Visit Lisa and family @ the old Daylight Donuts on Main St in Endwell. You will not be disappointed and they also sell a WIDE variety of Italian ice (with real fruit in it). Not the same ‘ol, same ‘ol (like that other place on Oak Hill)😉. Sammy’s Ice Cream and Italian Ice is...
Read moreBest CHOCOLATE ITALIAN ICE HANDS DOWN . But I would also like to thank their associate Ben for the out standing customer service he gives. I go their all the time ( very pregnant and their chocolate Italian ice is my Fav) sometimes they don't have it . Today they did and I went in with my husband to get some . I love how staff remembered me Ben made sure to lmk that he made some today (very much appreciated) 😀 it's was so dely as always. The owner should be very proud the place is always so clean and nice and more than anything friendly service...
Read moreI am from NC and I travel all over the east coast with my job. The title of this review is SPLENDIFEROUS!! I love to meet new friends and support the local businesses. All I can say is Sammy’s Ice Cream is off the chain!! From the time I walked in, Ashley, Robin & Lisa rolled out the red carpet! I was treated better than family and words cannot describe how awesome my sundae was! To all who read this, I highly recommend you stopping by Sammy’s and enjoy an amazing dessert! I will definitely stop in again when I’m back in town for work!...
Read more