Buntsy's Neighborhood Food and Drink — Restaurant in Town of Webster

Our first visit wasn't that good. We heard from a friend how great their wings were so we went to wing night. This place was slow... I understand that wings take time to cook but 50 minutes? We ordered 2 orders of 10 wings, onion rings and a carmel apple chicken salad. The onion rings would have been good had they been fresh. Half the onion rings looked and tasted like they were a few batches old and the other half had been sitting for at least 15 minutes. The wings were so over cooked that they litterally cut our mouths trying to tear them from the bone. To some over cooked is good but these were beyond that, to a point where the bones were so brittle they feel apart while trying to tear the meat from them. The worst part was they had so little sauce you couldn't tell the garlic parm from the smokey gold. Yes wings need lots of sauce! They litteraly had no sauce, just a little hint of butter maybe with parm cheese shaked on. Also whats with one small side of blue cheese? I was out of blue cheese after my 4th wing. The salad was awesome! Not worth the 50 minute wait but it was good. I have a feeling the waitress forgot our order and then tried rushing it out thus no sauce over cooked wings and stale onion rings. I gave two stars only because salad was good. We were both very disappointed in the wait, poor service...

We looked at the menu and pictures online and decided to give Buntsy's a try on a whim. Four of us ordered very different foods and overall the entrees were really good. The ribs were delicious, Home Plate was good, although my son thought there was too much mustard. The Caramel Apple Chicken salad was tastey. They accomodated my request for grilled chicken instead of fried without a problem. However, I was charged an extra $3.99 for my request. The kids chicken fingers were very crispy. We also ordered the Drunkin Poutine appetizer with our meals. Disappointing! The preparer neglected to put the final ingredients on the dish and sent it out half done. It was a mediocre $11 plate of fries with a couple dollops of cheese and the gravy tasted like it was from a jar. I pointed it out to the waitress and she removed it from our bill. After eating, we decided to try 2 of the amazing looking milkshakes, with alcohol. The flavors were great! Super pricy tho: $10 each before the alcohol is a bit ridiculous and $14 after seems a bit more ridiculous. We expected a bit larger drink for that money. Wait staff was friendly and helpful. The bar was a little heavy on ice and light on alcohol for a mixed drink. We spent waaaay more money ($110) than we expected and half of it was drinks and milkshakes. I am not impressed...

I had been waiting to come to Buntsy's as I love local places. I took my kids last weekend an below is my review. I am breaking my review into separate sections because some aspects were better than others.

Atmosphere: The dinning room felt detached from the identity of restaurant. I went stopped in the bar after to see what it was like in there and it was very lively and had a good feel.

Service: Our waitress was efficient with her role and told us about future events at Buntsy's.

Drink: I order the Buntsy's Punch and was really disappointed. For a cocktail that has your name in it I would have expected better presentation and taste. The cocktail was heavy on the red bull and the lime lime soda was flat. However the Genesee Light was perfect as always.

Appetizers: We ordered the Mozzarella Sticks and Boneless Wings tossed in Smoky Gold Sauce . Both appetizers were good but the wing sauce was outstanding!

Main Course: We all got burgers the kids each got the Singleman w/fries and I got the Buntsy's burger. The burgers were good the fries were warm and soft.

I will be back as I feel you can't blacklist a restaurant only after a hand full of attempts. When I do go back I will make sure to be in the bar area and will definitely getting the wings with the...