The Eatery — Restaurant in Wallingford

(Last visited January 10, 2025.) I've been coming to The Eatery in Wallingford for safe-to-say, years. A few of my foodie friends put me on game regarding this place that's about a 25-minute drive for me, but always so worth it. Here's why I love it so much!

Atmosphere/Appearance: Set in the center of Wallingford a little off of the main drag of Center Street is this humble gem. You can park on the street for free if there's space or in the plaza parking lot right up the block from them. Once in the door you're welcomed by several smiling faces and that makes ALL THE DIFFERENCE! This place is predominately made for takeout. There are no physical tables, but you certainly can pop a squat on the benches near the back of the restaurant if you'd like.

Service: There isn't necessarily table service since all you do is order at the counter and wait until your name is called, but the people there are so sweet, soft and will just make your day! They're also full of personality and their social media posts are super funny. Lol.

Food: I've had several things from their menu here including the Backyard BBQ Sandwich, Savannah Wrap, Vegan BBQ Mac & Jack Bowl, The Hungry Slope, BCB, Roast Beef and more! These are some of the highest quality, made-with-love sandwiches, tastiest, creative sandwiches around! I just love how every several months they change the menu up introducing new flavors for the season so you never know what you're gonna get! Of course the favorites stay on the menu!

Value: These sandwiches aren't cheap, but you have to pay for quality. Expect to spend between $11.00 and $15.00 here for a good meal. Then add on whatever else for drinks or sides, but it's worth it.

In conclusion, I love this place, I just wish they were closer AND that they were opened on weekends, but they keep the hours tight to allow their employees to have lives. I give them even more respect for that! Check this...

Very small cute place but I already knew it was going to be from the pictures on here. I was lookin for a cute, small, and quaint cafe that sold hot tea, but we don't have many of those nearby where I live. I found one, but decided to try this place first as it had a better rating and I was not disappointed. As soon as my boyfriend and I walked in we were greeted by a woman who I had assumed was the owner. She was extremely friendly, talking with us as we had never visited this place before. She was even patient with my boyfriend who couldn't decide XD much more patient than I have ever been. Even though the place is very homey and so familiar feeling, the food was very elegant. Plated beautifully, and presented beautifully. I got a salad and it was definitely something i had never tasted before. Out of my comfort zone but I must say it was amazing. Everything that was put into that salad complimented everything else. My boyfriend fell in love with the cranberry jalepenio relishing his sandwich. The only bad thing would probabaly be the parking, as it was our first time being there we didn't know where to park. There's a parking lot right next to the building, but they will tow you. Didn't realize the actual parking lot was behind the place but you can't get to it from the front so we just parked on the street right in front of the place. I had a great experience and you...

In additional to their normal hours, The Eatery is now open Saturdays from 10am-2pm for the summer and I am SO happy! The workers are bubbly and inviting. The interior is bright, and although it does not have tables, they do have bench style seating inside and outside.

There are some great seasonal specials to keep an eye out for. My mom tried the backyard BBQ sandwich and California salad, which she loved. I ordered the Chipotle Roast Beef Melt, but substituted the meat with chicken. Loaded with Cheddar and American cheese, chipotle aioli, grilled red onions, sweet pickled jalapeños on a grilled ciabatta. Will definently be back for another. Their new agua frescos are also a great addition to the summer menu. I got the strawberry watermelon mint - so refreshing.

Their menu is large and offers salads, sandwiches, wraps, bowls, and even a donut breakfast sandwich!...