Tofte's Table — Restaurant in Waukesha

Waukesha is truly blessed with a vibrant dining scene, and Tofte's Table is a shining example of what makes this city such a great place for foodies. Exceptional doesn’t even begin to describe it! From the moment we walked through the door, we knew we were in for an incredible evening.

The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and intimate. The service? Top-notch. Our server was not only extremely knowledgeable about the menu but also made sure we had everything we needed. And the care they took to accommodate Anne’s gluten-free needs? Absolutely above and beyond. They didn’t just meet expectations; they exceeded them in every way.

Of course, the star of the evening was the food. We decided to go all in with the Chef’s Selection, a seven-course surprise tasting menu. Even though we were a party of four (and one gluten-free), they graciously made it happen for us. Every dish was amazing, both in presentation and flavor. Here’s a taste of what we had:

Duck Confit ‘Tostada’ – Crispy wonton topped with duck confit, shiitakes, bok choy, queso fresco, sesame tomatoes, and hoisin. A perfect start with layers of flavor.

Fried Chicken – This simple dish blew us away! Perfectly crispy drumsticks with coarse mustard, honey, and a maple drizzle. And the gluten-free version for Anne? Absolutely amazing and an unexpected treat. This might have been our favorite of the night!

Tomato & Burrata – Charred roma tomatoes paired with creamy burrata, red onion jam, basil olive oil, and balsamic glaze, served with grilled ciabatta. A fresh and flavorful highlight a real table pleaser.

Wisconsin Kielbasa – Butternut and russet hash, sautéed kale and Brussels sprouts, pickled red cabbage, and coarse mustard aioli. This dish brought together the perfect balance of savory and tangy.

Gulf Shrimp – Sautéed shrimp served over cheese ravioli with a sun-dried tomato cream, sautéed shallots, spinach, red bell peppers, asparagus, and fried parsnips.

Braised Short Ribs – Melt-in-your-mouth short ribs over parmesan risotto, with honey-glazed carrots and radishes in a rich braising reduction. The definition of elevated comfort food.

And for dessert? Sticky Toffee Bread Pudding and a Flourless Chocolate Cake (GF). Both were decadent, indulgent, and the perfect way to end an unforgettable meal.

The evening was nothing short of fantastic, and we can’t thank Jason and Cristina Tofte enough for the impeccable experience they’ve created. From the thoughtful accommodations to the warm, welcoming atmosphere, everything about Tofte’s Table is designed to make you feel at home while treating you to something truly special.

If you haven’t been yet, make a reservation and prepare for an unforgettable evening. Tofte’s Table is not just a restaurant—it’s a destination every foodie needs to visit!

We’ll...

Went to Tofte's for the first time on a Friday night. The interior was warm and beautifully decorated for the holidays. It was great to see the old architecture maintained, with the vintage tin ceilings and natural brick. We sat at the bar and were greated cheerfully. Everything was explained to us, no dropping menus and leave. What struck me, is how well she knew the menu! Everything was described and explained as if she made it. She had a level of passion for the entire menu, which I've never seen from staff. We decided on the meat and cheese plate, the crispy pork belly and the duck confit tostada. The tostada came first and it was THE BEST I've had! The wonton was perfectly crisp, the duck was moist and flavorful and was the star. The toppings were just enough without overwhelming the duck. The meat and cheese platter was generous and came with a clever little "road map". Too often, after the server leaves, I find myself saying, " what was that"? So the "map" was a great addition! This platter was more than adequate for two. The cheeses and meats were harmonious with each other. Little hits of sweetness were provided by honeycomb, dried craisins and an INCREDIBLE onion jam!!!! Holy moly! I'll take a quart of that stuff! Then we got the pork belly. It was supple and flavorful. Unfortunately, I was already a tad full from the tostada and meat/cheese platter! It was ALL delicious!!!! I can't wait to get back and try some of the other items on the menu! The staff are FANTASTIC, the owners were gracious and humble and the food is DELICIOUS!! Tofte's is definitely a place to go for a night of conversation or an elegant meal. It's exquisite small plates without pretension and without being over priced. Tofte's is a hidden jewel...

WOW. This is high cuisine, with incredible flavor combinations, presentation, and everything was delicious. This is also small plate/sharing type of meal. We ordered an entree and all shared each entree with a table of 5. The food was always enough for all of us, and we got around 3 or 4 entrees and dessert. Brussel Sprouts were delish,

We had the Chicken and Waffle (I'm a chicken and waffle gal- but this was just a bit different. Bone In Chicken, and a lot of different flavors with Orange zest, and Different Maple flavor.. it was kind of a lot- so don't expect a normal chicken and waffle, this is a totally different sweet and savory and citrus experience.

We also had a few Appetizers and dessert. The flour less chocolate cake was VERY DECADENT. Shared amongst 5, big slice but each bite is so rich.

And the Cheesecake- again so many flavors but it was mind blowingly good. Not too sweet, but again, you only need a small amount to be satisfied.

This is an evening of sharing a colorful and adventure for the tastebuds for friends. Do not expect a standard American meal where the point is to eat as much as you can for less. No no. This brings back the joy of food and eating together again. The joy of trying the invention of flavors and cuisine genius.

And with small shareable plates it's emphasized in a beautiful way.

The atmosphere also feels intimate with dimmed lighting and quite fancy. You NEED a reservation, or call ahead to reserve if they have an opening. They were able to accommodate us even though we called day of and added another person. But not always because its not a super large dining room.

Just excellent. And the prices were quite reasonable, especially if you...