Jersey Cookie Girl — Local services in Millstone Township

I recently had the pleasure of ordering custom cookies for a graduation party, and I couldn't be happier with the results. From start to finish, the experience was outstanding. The cookies were not only visually stunning but also absolutely delicious. Each cookie was a work of art, meticulously decorated to match our graduation theme perfectly. The attention to detail was incredible, making the cookies a true highlight of the celebration.

The ordering process was seamless, and Nicole was incredibly responsive and accommodating. She listened to all our ideas and brought them to life in the most beautiful way. Guests at the party were raving about the cookies, and many asked for contact information so they could order for their own events.

If you're looking for beautifully crafted, delicious cookies for any special occasion, I highly recommend the NJ Cookie Girl. Their talent and professionalism are unmatched, and I will definitely be ordering from them again for future events. Thank you for making our graduation party...

One star because she clearly has talent. Unfortunately, that talent is eclipsed by a nasty attitude and an inattention to detail. I ordered a tray of graduation themed cookies for my daughter's graduation. Imagine my surprise when I opened the tray and found that she had given us 8 custom college cookies... with the wrong college on them!! The invoice, btw, had the correct name on it. Her solution was simply "to remove them from the tray", leaving me with a sloppy, unimpressive tray that looked half eaten, and then offered me a refund equal to just more than 2 custom cookies (despite 8 being wrong). There were minor errors with some of the other cookies as well, like a lack of sugar crystals and the wrong color outlining but I would've gladly overlooked that if not for the college screw up. To top it off, she never offered any apology for ruining my daughter's graduation party dessert, instead acting indignant and offering excuses. Horrible...

I first ordered Jersey Cookie Girl five years ago off of an advertisement on Facebook. It was last minute and I needed for my daughters Sweet 16. Not only was Nicole eager to help me - she made it easy for las minute pickup at a meeting place. The cookies were beautifully decorated - almost too pretty to eat. But when the kids kept coming up to me, during the party, asking if I had any more cookies I had to try and all I have to say is AMAZING. They are the best sugar cookies I have ever had - being a mom I am somewhat of a connoisseur! I am a repeat client at Jersey Cookie Girl because of the wonderful and creative products and also because I think the owner is a wonderful person. So kind and sweet.

I am giving FIVE STARS because I have so much faith that anyone ordering for the first time will be happy. Keep up...