Two Dog Night Creamery — Local services in Sebastopol

We saw the Peppermint Brownie Ice Cream Taco in Sonoma Magazine, and were excited about going to get one. What a disappointment when we tried this "treat."

DON'T get one of these ice cream tacos from Two Dog Night. I bought one yesterday for $8 and it was half-melted when they handed it to me. It was wrapped in stiff plastic, so it was difficult to know if it was solid or liquid, but when I sat down to open it, I realized that the ice cream had almost completely melted and the cone was soggy. I had asked about whether it should have some liquid in it and assumed that it was soft because it was some sort of mint topping. The girls behind the counter didn't answer me one way or another and they appeared to be distracted by something other than their customers. I can't believe they sold it to me like that. They looked in a couple of freezer/refrigerators down near the floor before they found one for me. I had expected it to be freshly made, but this one appeared to have been sitting around for days in what was clearly a not-cold-enough freezer. Don't buy these. What a rip-off, poor and careless service, and unhygienic food. I'm done with Two Dog Night. Stay away from this place. They'll serve you garbage if...

If you're looking for a charming, feel-good spot to satisfy your sweet tooth, this family-owned ice cream shop is a hidden gem. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and the kind of personal service you just can't get at big chains.

The ice cream itself is top-notch—creamy, rich, and clearly made with care. They offer a great variety of classic and creative flavors, many of which rotate regularly, so there's always something new to try. Standouts for me were the homemade waffle cones and their seasonal specials.

What really makes this place special is the love and attention behind everything they do. You can tell the family takes pride in their work, from the quality ingredients to the friendly conversations at the counter. It's the kind of place where kids light up, and adults find a little nostalgic joy.

Highly recommended for a treat that feels both indulgent...

Been wanting to go here for a while and finally made the trip this evening. The ice cream….is just ok. I got the sundae with brownies and banana foster ice cream. I love banana ice cream and this was a big miss for me, unfortunately. The ice cream is smooth and creamy, a little on the sweet side but I didn’t taste much banana and it just lacked flavor. Banana ice cream is hard to find so when a place carries it i usually get it. The brownie pieces I am assuming were bought in bulk and offered nothing to the Sundae…the mini chocolate chips were a little on the older side (coating on the outside). For a place that is charging a decent amount for this ice cream I kind of expected something a bit more special. there are a few other amazing ice cream shops locally and this is one I unfortunately won’t be coming back to. They have a great selection and the staff was nice which is...