One of the island's most endearing and enduring icons just like the lighthouse. Have been buying things here since I was a kid in the 80's. Its now an annual pilgrimage for me. Can you find things cheaper? Probably. But that's not the point. Its about supporting local, family owned businesses that have stood the test of time and brutal Internet. Its about supporting the local business communities that make LBI unique and memorable. The store staff members are incredibly friendly and always have really interesting new things to buy in the model section. Think of it this way. Toys R Us no longer exists along with a long list of other major businesses yet the Haymarket is still standing. It's a labor of love so please...
   Read moreI've been coming to the beach for the past 10 years and I didn't even realize this toy store was here! It's a wonderful store. It's jam-packed with every toy a kid could want. From Legos to model planes to all kinds of board games and trinkets. They have all of the old school toys and the new trendy stuff as well. I was...
   Read moreThis decently sized shop has a surprisingly good selection of board games, models, and toys. The prices are reasonable and don't have the resort/beachtown markup that some places tend to add. The staff were really nice and not pushy or stalk you around the store as though you're going to...
   Read more