Yoder's Meat & Cheese Co — Local services in Shipshewana

The store is impeccably clean and well-organized, offering a variety of fresh produce, farm-fresh dairy products, homemade baked goods, and hand-crafted items that you won’t find anywhere else. The baked goods—especially the pies, breads, and cookies—are simply divine, with flavors that remind you of home-cooked meals made with love. Their deli section, featuring smoked meats and cheeses, is a must-visit as well.

What truly sets this store apart is the sense of community and authenticity. The staff are incredibly friendly, knowledgeable, and always willing to help. They take pride in their products and are happy to share stories about how items are made, adding a personal touch to the shopping experience.

Prices are reasonable, considering the exceptional quality and care that go into every product. Whether you’re stocking up on pantry staples, buying a special treat, or just exploring, this Amish grocery store is a treasure trove of delights. It’s a place you’ll want to return to again and again—not just for the products, but for the heartwarming experience itself. Highly...

A MUST STOP if you're in Shipshewana!

If you've never tried their Bourbon Glazed Pork Chops (available in store only) you're missing out on some of the most tender, flavorful pork chops of your life! I seriously couldn't believe how their house-made glaze soaked that delicious, rich bourbon flavor through the entire pork chop. There's just no comparison between big box and Yoder's when it comes to the quality and flavor of their steaks, sirloin burgers, and pork.

It's absolutely worth a stop here not only for their meat but experience their entire store and staff. Everyone is always so friendly and helpful. I'm also probably going to gain weight thanks to the sheer amount of new kinds of Amish made cheeses I picked up to try. You can't go wrong with the smoked bacon gouda, and they'll even slice it for you at the deli counter!

My kids also love the snack and candy aisle and beg to pick up the chocolate milk every time we go. I love to grab their kettle corn for the drive home, and I always make a trip to pick up dip mixes and soup mixes before...

This is a fantastic place if you like "quality meat and cheese". We packed 2 empty coolers with us to fill it up with meat and cheese. We bought ribeye, NY strip, beef brisket, pork chops, ground pork, and different types of cheese. They also sell ice bags so that you can pack your coolers. Every meal we ate so far with their meat has been delicious. They are hand-cut and has very very little fat. It is tender and tastes good. After eating their meat, I don't feel like buying meat from supermarkets ! I am encouraged to find local butchers and buy hand-cut fresh meat. I will definitely visit them more often and buy meat and cheese. If you do the math, you will find out that there is 30-40% fat in meat from supermarkets and the cost from local butcher would offset even though the price is slightly higher (maybe 20-25%). Overall, you break even and end up with good quality meat. We bought some cheddar and mozzarella. It is amazingly good. I am extremely satisfied with their products and highly recommed every visitor to...