Oakdale Antiques Plaza — Local services in Town of Islip

Kirk is a very down-to-earth person to work with. He was able to fix up my grandfather's watches after his passing, which let me continue to wear them. He replaced 2 of the bands as well, since I have very small wrists, and made sure I was happy with the finished result.

I had sold him a pocket watch, and the chain turned out to be made of 14k gold. Instead of keeping this to himself, he reached out to me and gave me extra money for it. I had no idea it was made of anything special at all.

I always come to Oakdale when I'm looking for something specific, or even browsing or passing through. It's a little drive from Mount Sinai, but it's well worth it knowing that I'm dealing with an...

I feel bad for only getting around to writing this review now but better late then never. I’ve known Joe for about 7 years or so through a family member who passed away about 5 years ago. In his passing we were left with a large amount of antique clocks, trains, etc and really didn’t know where to go or what to do. Joe was a major help to my brother and I in selling items in store and connecting us with other people he knew who would be interested or could assist with some auction sales. He really is a true gentleman, extremely honest and runs a great shop. People like him are truly hard to come by now and I really can’t thank him enough for the help he provided during our...

Love this place!! They have a little bit of everything and more lol. Plus the owner is extremely knowledgeable and fair.

I couldn’t believe it but this one time he bought something I had brought to him to sell and when I went back a few weeks later he had money put aside in an envelope for me bc he said the item was actually worth more then what he had originally paid me!! I said wow that’s really honest of you… I would have never known and he said but I would!!

It’s rare to meet people as trustworthy and honest as that especially in that industry. I’ll never go...