Out of the Past Antiques — Local services in West Cape May

Super cool little place. Me and my friends are all into collecting anything we find cool. Sports cards, old bottles, magazines. You name it and I’m sure we’ve bought it. We’re all in high school so whatever money we have we spend on the weekends at antique stores across Cape May. This was my first time stopping in here even though I’ve passed it a million times. Quite a variety of different stuff for a place so small. Some things I collect are matchbooks and coins/ tokens. So I ended up buying a WWII rations token and a pack of matches for only 2 dollars. And my girlfriend got a picture Barbara Streisand, which the woman there gave her a couple of dollars off, for and an old map of New Jersey. She also gave us postcards that have a picture of the store on the front for free. Really cool place and I’ll definitely be...

Hidden Gem for Antique Lovers

Out of the Past Antiques in Cape May is an absolute treasure trove. I stopped in recently and was blown away by how rare and unique the items are—clearly the result of years of thoughtful curation by the owner. Every corner of the shop is beautifully organized, making it easy and enjoyable to explore. I ended up purchasing two special pieces that I am thrilled to take home. The owner was incredibly kind and welcoming, adding a personal touch that made the experience even better. This is a must-visit for any...

My wife and I came in during a day trip and it was a great little shop to see old things. Jeanne was great to talk with. She was very knowledgable about everything in the store and we had a great time talking with her and learning about the stuff she buys. The things in the store have memories or history attached to them, and my wife and I loved perusing them and learning about that history. Will definitely go back next time we're...