Cape May Sports Memorabilia — Local services in West Cape May

Not an actual shop but rather two stalls in a tiny antiques mall. There’s some vintage baseball, a few stacks of vintage football cards, and hundreds of 2022-2024 repacked hanger base Score team sets (any of value are in showcases and overpriced by any metric). There’s a few boxes of low grade “star” singles but they appear to have been picked over for years. There’s an off center 1981 Ken Anderson card with a dinged corner for you Bengals fans. Everything was priced at +50-100% eBay sold comps. Most prices are not visible and require flagging down an antique mall attendant to open a showcase. There’s some magazines and other ephemera to browse. Basically, this isn’t worth going out of your way unless you’re already in Cape May with your family and need a break. I’d love to support LCSs but I’d like to warn folks to not get...

UPDATE: Changing my review to 5 stars. Mike came through and made up for the missing card and then some! Don't miss this card shop. We'll be back next year!

Got a nice set of 1989 Fleer baseball cards yesterday for my son. He was super excited for a piece of baseball history and all the hall of famers from when I was a kid.

The box said it was complete but missing Bill Ripken card (616). Whether it was the original card with error removed, or the edited version, we were both disappointed. On closer inspection the “factory sealed” sticker had a piece of Scotch tape over it. A nice (incomplete) set...

We visit Cape May several times a year and my son makes sure we visit Mike's shop every time (well, multiple times per trip, LOL). Last time we had the pleasure of meeting Mike personally and he was so incredibly kind to my son- gave him some great deals and even threw in a few packs of cards for free. He has a ton of stuff and is in business to help make folks happy and start or add to their collection, rather than to solely make a profit. We will definitely return again and again!...