We ate lunch at Penelope's. For appetizer we took Fried Tomato Fritters, they were crispy and delicious. For main dishes we took Cycladic Pasta and Greek Meatballs. The pasta was pretty good, it had a delicious tomato sauce around it and some feta cheese on top of it. The Greek meatballs was good too, very tender meat (would've loved if it had a little bit more salt doe) and the tomato sauce combined with feta cheese and cut up fries made the dish complete (bit overpriced since I paid 19,50€ for 5 meatballs).

I'm giving it 3* because we had a "bad" encounter with the customer service there. Basically the place was packed and we had to wait for 15 minutes to be seated on the table (we just went to the first table that was freed). And another 15 min for our orders to be taken. After we were finished with the food, we asked for our check but there was none to be seen for 20 minutes (note that sll of this happened because there was only 1 waiter the whole time we were there, male, absolutely lovely guy) so we had to personally go search for free staff downstairs to get our check (found a woman). After making the payment she asked if we would like to tip and we said no because we didn't feel like it since the wait times made it very unpleasant. Then she started to guilt trip us to try to get us to give them tips and overall left a bad taste in our mouth.

Overall pretty good food so recommend to visit if you're sightseeing in Pyrgos and don't mind the wait times.