Pizza Bella Isla Mujeres - Italian Restaurant — Restaurant in Isla Mujeres

I really wanted to give this place 5 stars. On our 4th night on the island after having so much Mexica food, we decided for a change and try this place out. We went on a very very rainy night, I mean the rain water was running down the street.

There was a sign that read “Free beer with your favorite pizza” I wish I would have gotten a pic of that. But anyways, I ordered the bruschetta to start, shrimp Alfredo pasta, and the Margherita pizza with half of the Pepperoni Rica. This was absolutely delicious and so fresh! The pizza dough was freshly made and you could taste the freshness and airiness to the dough. The pasta sauce was amazing and didn’t need anything else. The female waitress even gave us lemon shots at the end free of charge as we expressed to her how amazing the food was.

Since our experience was so amazing, we agreed to come back on the last night. Unfortunately our experience this time around was not the best. We decided to try a new pizza called Caprichosa Blanca. It tasted old, as if it had been done earlier that day and re heated for us. The appetizer we decided to go with this time around was nothing to rave about, which was the Jamón Serrano y Burrata.

And to end this review, we never got the free beer 😐. So don’t forget to ask for...

we've been on vacation here for the past 6 days and ate here 4 out of those 6 nights if that tells you something about this place. absolutely amazing pizza, Nutella roll, and pastas!! we had the 4 Carnes every time and it never disappointed once. it's true Italian style pizza, hand tossed dough.

we had every person here as a waiter/waitress and zero complaints from them all! Marcos was our last one and left a lasting impression on top quality service and taking care of us. the manager even let us borrow 60 pesos for my daughter to buy a ice cream next door after dinner as we had no cash on us, and didnt know they didnt accept card.

absolutely perfect staff and great people I would love to hang out with and get to know if I lived here! shout out to the manager I never caught her name but she took care of us every night and left a lasting...

I recently visited this restaurant and was absolutely blown away! 🍕 The pizza was incredible – perfectly crispy, full of flavor, and you can really taste the care and quality in every bite.

The owners are so warm and welcoming that you immediately feel at home. The restaurant itself is beautifully decorated, with lovely lighting and a cozy, inviting atmosphere. They often have live music in front of the restaurant, which makes the whole experience even more enjoyable. It’s such a beautiful place that you could easily spend hours just sitting, relaxing, and enjoying the ambiance.

All in all, a true gem – I’ll definitely be...