Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops — Restaurant in Alpharetta

Great tasting savory and sweet pies!

It’s strictly to-go only. No chairs or tables. Also note that on Fridays they have Free Pie Friday where they give you a free slice of pie. How awesome!

They have different sizes for their pies: petite or the regular standard size. The petite is larger than I thought, good enough for two servings!

They have some interesting savory options such as chicken ranchero (I believe it was described as an enchilada-type of pie), southwestern taco, pot roast, and of course chicken pot pie. Some sweet options include chocolate chess, French custard, buttermilk, key lime pie, pecan, and more.

Got the chicken pot pie for lunch, which they warmed up for me. Also got a petite buttermilk pie and a slice of chocolate chess pie. Everything was tasty. The pie crusts were buttery. The chicken pot pie was comforting and just a classic in terms of taste. Really everything I could want or ask for from a chicken pot pie. The portion is great for lunch.

The buttermilk pie has a custard type filling. The chocolate chess pie was good too. I don’t eat sweets often so I would say the chicken pot pie was my favorite.

Service was great. The employees are so kind and friendly - really loved their energy and pleasant demeanor!

Will definitely be back...

The pies are excellent; the subpar review is due to the chaos surrounding our order at Thanksgiving. I was passed off to 3 different employees in trying to place an order. Then, despite giving them payment info, I was called back a short while later b/c they had misplaced the payment info and needed to take it again. Worst by far, however, was being told I would be fine to pick up the pie the morning of Thanksgiving, then driving over there to find the place closed. We had to scramble to find a grocery store pie to take to Thanksgiving dinner. When we called after the holiday, they apologized as they said they had also misplaced our contact number as they would have tried to contact us the day before Thanksgiving to confirm when we would be picking up.

They issued a refund, which was the bare minimum they could have done, but I would be hesitant to order through them again around a holiday/busy...

Well, well I am back!! Let’s see: Starting off with a positive note; the Buttermilk Chess really is good. I give it alone a 4-star, but I really cannot say the same for the Chocolate Chess or the Apple Turnover. For me they both lack flavor. I was looking for a rich and sweet chocolate taste and was not pleased with the mixture. Maybe bc I am from Texas we do it a bit different but nonetheless it was not that sweet. The apple was a miss for me due to the apple mixture. Again maybe bc we do it different but I was expecting an apple filling to ooze from my pie and it was dry😝. The pretty glaze look fooled me. This place was extremely pretty, clean, and has some of the best customer service I experienced in a long time. They offer savory pies as well but you are on your own. No one makes a better chicken pot pie than me!😁So add an additional star for kindness and...