Half decent. Was expecting a far better variety of seafood options though. Been to seafood buffets in Pittsburgh with a much stronger assortment of options actually and that is saying something. If you are taking kids who are of ages that no longer qualify for the children's buffet pricing, maybe circle the buffet before ordering to make sure there are enough appealing options to them in order to make the price tag worth it. My 12-year-old who is very picky but loves seafood wasn't keen on the style of many of the options so simply picked at her plate and then upgraded to crab legs which are a separate fee as they are not included in the buffet. So paying over $75 alone for her to eat a fraction of a plate from the buffet and then admittedly tasty, but very skinny crab legs was kind of insane even for Disney pricing. I feel like Cape May should also have a vegetarian option in pricing as my wife is a vegetarian and simply ate some salad which she said was good but obviously not a $42 meal for her. My youngest who is 8 years old did qualify for the children's buffet and was excited that there were meatballs (as she is a meatball aficionado) but said they tasted worse than the meatballs at her school cafeteria so she passed on those. She did really enjoy the corn on the cob though, haha. I was excited about the paella but truthfully it was maybe a 6 out of 10 if I'm being nice, not nearly enough proteins included within the rice. The waitress was super nice though and the highlight of the meal. All in all, we visit Disney every year and I'm very used to (and okay with) paying well over $125 for a meal for a family of five at most Disney restaurants and rarely have ever left dissatisfied. But a $285 visit to Cape May Cafe with three members of my family who barely touched their plates is very difficult to justify. Like I said, circle the buffet when you get there (as I wish I had) for my kids/wife to decide if it will be worth it for you.