Eugene O'Neill's — Restaurant in Boston

My partner and I have lived in Jamaica Plain for over two years and were looking forward to our first experience at Eugene O'Neill's. We could not be more disappointed and disheartened with our experience. To cut the story short there was a disruptive belligerent customer at the bar who was out of line. He was screaming from the moment we entered the restaurant. But his comments went from loud and disruptive to hateful and harmful quickly. He made homophobic comments regarding that JP is getting taken over by queer folks using homophobic slurs. The bartender was quick to respond and reprimand him and threaten to kick him out, but unfortunately that was not enough to stop the customers hate speech. A queer couple immediately left the restaurant when this nonsense started. The customer then went on to harass and argue with other customers minding their own business. He screamed at another customer saying that "HE WAS NOT WHITE" because the man identified as Italian. He then went on to comment on the color of the customers skin, saying his dark not white and had such dark skin. That customer left. Next, he approached another customer minding their business "IM A BAD GUY AND ILL HURT PEOPLE LIKE YOU, YOU BETTER WATCH OUT". I informed my waiter that this customer is dangerous and really should be asked to leave. The waiter said that they would inform their manager and see what can be done. The majority of the restaurant including my partner and I left to protect our own safety. We ordered a burger and cauliflower which took way to long, over 30 minutes, to arrive to our table. We will 100% not be coming back and it was not a safe space- especially to experience hate speech on Juneteenth and...

Eugene O'Neill's: A Hidden Gem by Forest Hills MBTA

Across the street from the Forest Hills MBTA bus station, Eugene O'Neill's exudes charm and warmth from the moment you step in. My recent lunch experience there was nothing short of delightful.

From the get-go, the service at Eugene O'Neill's was exceptional. Attentive and friendly staff made us feel welcome, setting the tone for a pleasant meal ahead. My friend and I opted for classics: a BLT with avocado and a Reuben, both served with steak fries.

The sandwiches were a revelation. The BLT, adorned with avocado, offered a refreshing twist on a beloved classic. Meanwhile, the Reuben boasted the perfect balance of flavors and textures, leaving us craving more with every bite. Accompanied by golden, crispy steak fries, each component of our meal was executed flawlessly.

What truly stood out, beyond the delicious food, was the ambiance. Eugene O'Neill's possesses an inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a casual lunch or a relaxed evening with friends. The cozy interior and welcoming vibe added an extra layer of enjoyment to our dining experience.

Overall, Eugene O'Neill's surpassed expectations in every aspect. From the impeccable service to the mouthwatering fare, it's evident why this establishment is a local favorite. As for me, I'll eagerly be back for more culinary delights and memorable moments at Eugene O'Neill's. Highly...

Fries aside, blandest food I’ve had in decades. My carrots (which were subbed in place for another vegetable without telling me in advance) were undercooked to the point of being raw. The Alfredo sauce (at least the waiter told me it was Alfredo) had zero flavor - no garlic, no Parmesan, not even salt or pepper. Weirdly flavorless. Ditto for friend’s gravy, and their broccoli was cooked into mush. Wouldn’t have eaten if I wasn’t starving. Thankfully another friend shared their fries and those were fantastic, so maybe they have other good recipes. Could be cook specific too. Who knows. First and last time coming here.

Oh, and the guy who took our drink orders took ages to get to our table especially considering the place was empty, seemed annoyed while taking them, then went back to playing a handheld video game. Nobody asked how the meals were. Very hands off. Maybe that’s the style here.

Did lunch earlier in the day next door at Brassica and the service and food were both fantastic. So if you...