Nice Guys Pizza, Beer, and Cocktails — Restaurant in Cape Coral

My visit to Nice Guys Pizza was nothing short of fantastic. I went with my wife and mother-in-law, and we all had an amazing time from start to finish. The atmosphere of the place was vibrant and unique, with a mix of modern and retro elements that made it stand out from your typical pizza joint. One of the highlights for us was the pinball machines—such a fun touch! We played a few rounds while waiting for our food, which made the experience even more enjoyable.

Now, let’s talk about the food—because that’s what really made this place special. We ordered the hot garlic Parmesan wings, a large pepperoni pizza, and garlic knots, and everything exceeded our expectations. The wings were absolutely delicious—crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and coated in a flavorful garlic Parmesan sauce that had just the right amount of heat. The pizza was exactly what you’d want from a top-tier pizza place: a perfectly cooked crust that was crisp yet chewy, a well-balanced layer of sauce and cheese, and generous amounts of pepperoni. Every bite was a delight. The garlic knots were a perfect side, warm, fluffy, and bursting with buttery garlic flavor.

Beyond the food and atmosphere, the service was great. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Even though the place was busy, we never felt rushed or ignored. It’s always nice to see a restaurant that balances quality food with great service and a fun, welcoming environment.

Overall, Nice Guys Pizza is more than just a place to grab a bite—it’s an experience. Whether you’re a pizza lover, a pinball enthusiast, or just looking for a great spot to hang out with family and friends, this place has it all. We’ll definitely be...

Nice Guys is rewarding students who have completed their AR goals with a personal sized pizza for Free, as long as the teacher has partnered with them and hands out the coupon. Mia was lucky enough to get one. So for last day of school we took her and a friend there to redeem it. The kids loved it! The pinball machines were a hit! And as always the pizza is the best! Love that Nice Guys gives back to our kids. It shows just how amazing they are not just for us adults but our families too! We love Nice Guys Specialty pizzas and what better place to go for a New Year’s Eve dinner than a fav?! For years we’ve been loyal to Nice Guys, they really do stretch the idea of a pizza topping and meld wonderfully unexpected flavors together. It’s fun to eat and chat about, you really can’t go wrong with any of their pizza options. Don’t like crazy flavor combos? No biggie they have a build your own option! This visit, we tried The Heart Attack and really enjoyed it! We also had a house salad prior and were surprised with the yummy dressing on such a simple but tasty salad! For drinks the hubby went with a beer he was thrilled with and I chose the gypsy mojitos… both were fun and well done. We’ve never had a bad drink here. This place overall would be called fun and experimental! Our service was exemplary! We had to waiters checking on us and never needed anything! Seeing the staff work as a team to handle the busy times was a joy, as it showed that they loved where they worked and our opinions mattered. This restaurant has a dark atmosphere which creates an intimate space we find. One reason we love it! Plus it has so much music that we grew up on, from the Cure, to Nirvana and so much more. Puts some pep...

One of the coolest places on the Cape. Do you like Elvis Costello, The Jam, XTC, Joy Division, and or X. I hope so because that’s what you will be listening to while you eat delicious pizza among other interesting offerings (such a mountains of tater tots with an array of house made dipping sauces, and vegan corn dogs). The food, art, music, unique specialty cocktails and staff bring together a one of a kind restaurant experience. A trip to the unisex bathrooms will exhilarate your punk sensibilities. Wonderfully vulgar amateur graffiti and stickers abound. Don’t come with your family. It’s not intended to be kid friendly so it’s not, thank god!

My only beef is with the name of their peanut butter topped pizza, “Washington Carver” it’s wonderful and a must try. However, Mr. Carver had nothing to do with the invention or production of peanut butter.

NOTE: Marcellus Gilmore Edson, a Canadian, is often credited with the first patent related to peanut butter in 1884. He developed a process to grind roasted peanuts into a paste. Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, the American physician known for creating cornflakes, patented a process in 1895 for creating peanut butter as a nutritious protein substitute for patients who had difficulty chewing. Dr. Ambrose Straub, another key figure, invented a machine in 1903 to make peanut butter on a larger scale, making it more widely available.

Bring some quarters ($1 per play) for the wall of pinball machines in a game area.

I updated this review after my 3rd visit last night to add more detail. I kept the rating at ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ because it’s top notch for what it’s...