Anthony's Pizza — Restaurant in City of Peekskill

Ordered a personal pie, zeppolis and a 20 oz Diet Coke from then on grub hub. The app said me order would be delivered between 7:55-8:05. When it hadn’t arrived I called the restaurant. The man who answered the phone said “we’re very busy I have to find your order” after overhearing him asking a few people about my order I was told my order hadn’t even been made yet, the man on the phone asked if I wanted to wait or cancel the order. I said I would wait and before I could ask for an answer estimate for delivery the man on the phone hung up on me. Unprofessional and rude.

This was my first order from Anthony’s. And it will be my last. Still haven’t received my pizza and don’t know if I’m going to...

Average pizza. Customer service needs help. Ordered a few pies (over the phone while at work) for my child's school a few months back and they delivered it to the wrong school! What made it worse was that the poor kids skipped lunch in anticipation of it. After calling them to check in on the order they lost touch with the delivery driver! Finally an hour later- they realized their error-- i asked for my money back (since the kids never got pizza and it was almost time for them to leave) and the manager insisted that he'd rush over the pies. It was too late! They had no remorse for their mistake and were nonchalant about the whole thing! I'll never spend another penny...

This is an amazing pizza parlor. My friends and I found each other stuck at Spins-on-Hudson, with at least 2 hours until their restaurant opened. We were stranded, starving, so we decided to make the journey to Anthony’s Pizza. We encountered multiple unexpected difficulties on the way, as we ran into train tracks. Through the pouring rain we made it through the treacherous weather, eventually seeing this great establishment. We walked in and automatically felt welcomed. We each ordered a slice and were amazed at the excellent...