Chicago's Pizza — Restaurant in Cloverdale

New to the area so I’ve ordered from Chicago’s Pizza 4 times, in the last three weeks, each time ordering 6-7 Large pizzas. The first time was great, the second time was great, the third time I noticed that it was significantly more cheese than the 1st & 2nd time I ordered. Therefore, I made sure to specifically order one of my seven pizzas with light cheese. Well I did not get light cheese, in-fact I got even more cheese on all the pizzas. I called to make this Cloverdale location aware that each time I order I’m getting more & more cheese but less toppings. After receiving a call back from the owner she instantly became rude and defensive. I explained to her that it was so much cheese that we couldn’t eat it and that I have 4 whole pizza left. “She said ma’am we measure the cheese and I know your pizzas were perfect, I served over 600 customers yesterday and not one person complained- I can’t give you your money back!” I then expressed to her that I wasn’t requesting any money back- I was simply asking that they be remade considering that each time I order my bill is well over $100. Just because no one else brought an issue to your attention doesn’t mean there were no issues. There’s ALWAYS room for improvement. The “Owner” would rather loose a great customer rather than make things right for the customer. No one is perfect, so we should all be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to...

Just took a business trip to Cloverdale, IN and found myself ordering dinner from this awesome place. One little caveat (and this isn't a negative, just a heads up) when I placed the order I got charged for 2 orders of wings instead of the single order and was told by the cashier this was a common thing with their register. Just a heads up, if this is a common thing makes sure you check your receipt. Anyway, for food I ordered an order of 12 wings with hot sauce and an all meat deep dish pizza. The wings were very good, not super hot/spicy and could have been a little crispier but I think they lost a tad in transportation back to the hotel. Flavor though was awesome, good wings! The pizza though, the pizza was amazing. Very thick, very cheesy, great toppings and not super dense crust. It was an amazing pizza I hope to some day get the opportunity to have again. Would highly recommend this place if you want a...

Staying in Cloverdale for a night, my dad and I were looking for a pizza place. We decided we would give this a whirl and we were very happy we did. The pizza was amazing. We got the normal crust with meat lovers and both of us really enjoyed it. The staff was wonderfully polite, everyone had smiles and was pleasant. I seen someone complain about the time but 15-20 minutes is pretty standard for a pizza place, many times it is longer depending how busy it is. It was Saturday night and it was right around the 15-20 minute mark (for fresh pizza that's great regardless). I am not sure if this is a chain or just a local place (I can't recall ever seeing another one around). Sadly, the likelihood of being able to return will probably be slim, but if I was in the area, this would be one of my go to for pizza. Would recommend and...