Wise Guys Pizza — Restaurant in Columbia Township

We are from out of town, visiting family in the hospital. Was really craving some good pizza. They say hole-in-the-wall restaurants usually have the best food. That's exactly what this place is. At least as an out-of-towner, it felt like a secret place. It's in the back room of a bar, and they literally have a counter and a window that you can see a giant kitchen through.

The food.... Oh my God. I got a 10" order of cheese sticks and a 14" deep dish supreme. The smell that hit me when they put my food on the counter was like nothing I've smelled before. My mouth instantly watered.

I didn't get to start eating my food for about an hour after I got it. It was somehow still hot, and let me tell you, that was the absolute best pizza I've ever had the pleasure of eating. Every bite was perfect. The crust was incredible. The cheese sticks were basically a giant pile of melted mozzarella with garlic and a little bread. I say that in a good way. They were amazing. We stuck the pizza in our hotel fridge and had some cold for breakfast today. I don't know how their pizza improved in the refrigerator overnight, but somehow it did.

If you get a chance to visit this place, do it. I'm sure all the locals are like "yeah, Wiseguys, everyone knows that place" but I'm going to call it a secret restaurant anyway. 10/10, will absolutely miss this pizza...

Wiseguys pizza is an absolute gem for any pizza lover out there! This pizza joint has everything you could want in a pizza place: delicious, high-quality ingredients, friendly and efficient service, and a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

The pizzas at Wiseguys are simply amazing. Every bite is filled with flavor and texture that will leave you craving for more. The crust is crispy on the outside yet chewy on the inside, and the toppings are generously piled on to create a perfect balance of flavors.

But what really sets Wiseguys apart is their commitment to quality. You can taste the freshness of the ingredients with every bite, and the staff takes great care to ensure that each pizza is made to perfection. Plus, they offer gluten-free and vegan options, so everyone can enjoy their delicious pizza.

The service at Wiseguys is also top-notch. The staff is friendly and welcoming, always ready to answer your questions and provide recommendations. The atmosphere is cozy and casual, making it the perfect spot for a night out with friends or a family dinner.

Overall, Wiseguys pizza is an excellent choice for anyone looking for a high-quality, delicious pizza. Their commitment to quality ingredients, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere make it a top pick for pizza lovers everywhere. I highly recommend...

I will never be ordering from here again. Absolutely unreliable and the staff lie.

I ordered a BYO Pizza online at 5:45pm. The estimated delivery time was 7:00pm. It was a Saturday night, so I understand the longer wait time.

I call at 7:25pm to check the status of my pizza. I provide my name and address. The staff member tells me that their internet is down and it's causing a delay in order, but she just packed my pizza and the delivery driver is on the way.

I call again at 8:10pm to check the status of my pizza. Without providing any of my information a different staff member answers and tells me the same exact thing. That my pizza was just packed and on the way.

I told him that I would like to go ahead and request a refund. He tells me that it's already on the way. I explain to him that I called 45 minutes earlier and was told my pizza was on the way and I don't want a cold pizza.

He then asks me for my name to look up my order. He tells me that my order didn't go through. I tell him the charge to my card sure did and I would like a refund. He tells me that he will call his boss to take care of this.

Both of the staff members lied about my pizza being on the way and the second one even attempted to stop my refund request because "it was already on the way"....