Colton's Steak House & Grill — Restaurant in Conway

It has been a few years since I was at Colton's. I am pleased at how well they survived covid. One waitress, Elaine was very polite, personable and practiced. She had a way of knowing when we were ready for her and when we just needed a little more time. There were 3 in our party, all ordered different dinners and all were thrilled with what we received. Starting with the dinner rolls... they are wonderful! Melt in your mouth, must be careful as they will refill your basket and you want to leave room for your entree. I had Southwest Chicken Chipotle, described in the menu as chicken tips, peppers and sweet white onions grilled and served over rice pilaf with Chipotle sauce and two shrimp. For my side I selected baked sweet potato with cinnamon and sugar. I am including a picture. It tasted even better than it looked and was very filling. Since two of us were lady and we were more than an hour from home, we made the obligatory visit to the ladies room. Everything was clean and nicely appointed. While waiting for my friend I made a discovery. I was so surprised I point it out to the other patrons. Their pleasure in finding this hither to unheard of experience made me desire to share it with you. Attached is also a video of some very pleasant mouthwash provided free of charge in the ladies loo. For that bit of hospitality I would like to do something that is not my style. I would up this rating to 6 on a scale of 1-5 if only I could. Check it out! That's...

Walking into Colton’s Steak House & Grill in Conway, you’re greeted first by the rich aroma of steaks sizzling on the grill—a promise of hearty fare executed with confidence. The menu leans into comfort with classic favorites like ribeyes, filets, sirloins, and New York strips, each hand-cut and cooked to spec, ensuring the meat speaks for itself  .

On the side, indulgent options like loaded baked potatoes, creamy mac and cheese, and fluffy warm rolls elevate the dining experience beyond expectations. Guests have praised perfectly cooked rolls, grilled sirloins, and even fried chicken—testament to reliable execution across the menu  .

Seafood lovers aren’t left out: mesquite-grilled salmon, fried catfish, and shrimp offer flavorful alternatives that complement the beef selections well  .

Overall, Colton’s delivers on a straightforward but essential promise: satisfying, well-prepared food in a cozy, unpretentious setting. Whether you’re craving a meaty steak or flavorful seafood, it’s the kind of place where cravings are met—and then some. With an average rating hovering around four stars, it clearly hits the mark for...

We had not eaten there for a few years, and actually almost didn't eat there this time, due to the negative reviews we had read. But because it is becoming harder and harder to find a nice place to dine that doesn't serve alcohol, we decided to give it a try. I am so glad we did! Granted, we were there early (4pm) and the restaurant wasn't yet crowded, but we had a great experience. Our server Dyllen could not have been better! He was attentive without hovering: the perfect balance. He answered our questions, and seemed to know exactly when our drinks needed refilling. Our steaks were cooked to our exact specifications (sirloin tips medium well and Del-Rio ribeye well done), and were tender and delicious. The salad was fresh and crisp, the house dressing was tasty, and the baked potato was great. We passed on the homemade yeast rolls, but they looked amazing. We even enjoyed the free peanuts, and I'm thankful there were no shells on the floor to trip on! We will definitely dine...