Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️(3.5)

Upon entering May Kelly's cottage, the first impression may seem a bit disappointing. The establishment appears to be in need of some refurbishment, and the condition of the floor could be improved. However, it's important to remember that sometimes appearances can be deceiving, and there may still be positive aspects to discover within.

The décor isn’t align with the stereotypical Irish theme that one might expect, but it's essential to appreciate the uniqueness and individuality that May Kelly's cottage brings to the table. Sometimes, stepping away from the traditional can lead to unexpected surprises and a fresh approach to ambiance.

Let’s get to the food.

Appetizer:

May's Potato Cakes at May Kelly's cottage are an absolute treat for the taste buds. These delectable cakes are crafted with a perfect blend of mashed potato, scallions, cheese, and bacon. The combination of these ingredients creates a symphony of flavors that is both comforting and indulgent.

One of the highlights of these potato cakes is the impeccable cooking technique. Lightly floured and fried to a golden perfection, they are then oven-baked to ensure a crispy exterior while maintaining a soft and creamy interior. This careful preparation truly elevates the dish to a whole new level.

The presentation of the potato cakes is equally impressive. Served over a bed of dressed baby spinach, they create a visually appealing dish that instantly whets the appetite. The creamy horseradish sauce adds a tangy and zesty element that perfectly complements the richness of the potato cakes.

Dinner:

Our experience at dinner left much to be desired, particularly in regards to the food we ordered. We opted for the Classic Grilled Reuben, a beloved sandwich that has the potential to be a flavorful delight. However, what arrived at our table was a disappointing rendition of this classic dish.

The first issue we encountered was with the corned beef. Instead of being tender and succulent, it was dry and lacking in flavor. The lack of moisture made each bite a struggle, and it was clear that the beef had not been prepared with care or attention to detail.

Furthermore, the sauerkraut was noticeably lacking in tanginess, a crucial element in balancing the richness of the sandwich. Its lackluster taste left the overall flavor profile of the Reuben feeling flat and uninspiring.

The cheese was perfectly melted, but the its portion size its portion size was also commendable. The sandwich was generously filled with ample layers of swish cheese, ensuring every bite had a delightful cheesiness that made the Reuben truly delightful.

As for the Russian dressing, it was barely noticeable. The lack of any discernible flavor from the dressing left the sandwich feeling dry and lacking the necessary moisture to enhance the other ingredients.

The side of steak fries did not fare any better. They were clearly overcooked and lacked the desired crispness. Instead, they were greasy and unappetizing, leaving a heavy and unpleasant aftertaste.

Overall:

While the potato cakes were truly exceptional, the underwhelming Reuben and fries left a lot to be desired. However, May Kelly's cottage has demonstrated their ability to create standout dishes with the potato cakes, and it is worth giving their other offerings a chance. With their evident culinary prowess, it is likely that May Kelly's cottage can improve upon the areas that currently fall short.