Weâve been going to Insomnia Cookies for quite sometime since they opened up in Evansville, IN. We had the worst experience today. Just after 4pm, my girlfriend and I ordered four deluxe cookies. When we received them they werenât the right ones. My girlfriend and I had a conversation with the cashier and she said could give us a refund or print out our receipt for the order. She was rude to us and did not want to help us out at all. Is this normal if a customers order getâs messed up? Can the employees not fix your order or give you a refund? Sad part is she couldnât even print out the receipt to double check the order. Could the general manager or someone high up please get in contact with me? Our issue hasnât been resolved and the cashier took our money without a refund or fixing our...
   Read moreEDIT
WENT BACK HERE AGAIN A MONTH LATER, THOUGHT I'D TRY IT AGAIN. TO MY SURPRISE, I WAS GIVEN A PIECE OF MULCH!!! IN MY BOX!!! I DO NOT KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON, BUT YOU NEED TO FIGURE THIS OUT INSOMNIA! I ALMOST TOOK A BITE OF IT ONCE AGAIN. I DO NOT WANT TO EAT MULCH!! OR ROCKS!!! PLEASE REPENT.
ORIGINAL REVIEW
I go here weekly. I am known by name with all the employees. Today, I went like usual and one of the new guys was working. I left the store after purchasing a 6 pack of cookies. I got into my car and opened the box...
I wasn't looking when I grabbed and bit into one of the cookies I had bought. To my shock, I was given a ROCK instead of a cookie. Seth Berkowitz, PLEASE make this right. I am unsure when you started offering ROCKS as a menu item, but this is not...
   Read moreWe placed an online order. My boyfriend walked in there were three people in the regular line and then a separate part with a VERY VISIBLE SIGN that said ONLINE ORDERS PICK UP HERE. Since we placed an online order he stood there. They ignored him. The worker looked at him and he, being nice to everyone he meets like he does everywhere he goes, says how are you today ? She responded "you need something ?" He said I had an online order. She replied " it works better if you wait in line" he expressed that he had no problem waiting and apologized that he was just went there because of the sign. The worker went to the back and held out the order and shook it at him to come get it like he was a dog. I know people have bad days but there is no excuse for this unprofessional and honestly...
   Read more