Attardi's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Florida

We ordered pick up one week night at about 8ish. We ordered two orders of garlic knots, Buffalo chicken pizza, calzone, and an xl pepperoni pizza. We got the order and went back to our hotel room and were a little shocked at what we had actually received. We ended up with a BBQ chicken pizza instead of Buffalo, one slightly thrown together order of garlic knots that were half pepperoni rolls and half garlic knots and not the equivalent to the amount of knots we ordered it was very confusing. I tried to call back right away but it was about 8:45 and no one would pick up because they closed at 9. We weren't aware of their closing time, but someone knew they had just served us the pick up and it was wrong.

I called about quarter after 3 the following day since they wouldn't answer the phone the previous night. The gentleman on the phone was very polite and asked me if I wanted my order as a credit or a remake and apologized and said he would make it right even though he wasn't sure what had happened that he wasn't there the prior night. He asked me what time I wanted to pick up the remake and he would have it ready. We showed up at the time we had told him to pick up the garlic knots and the Buffalo chicken pizza and they were both amazing!!! The accidental BBQ chicken pizza was also amazing and the garlic knots/added in random pepperoni rolls were also amazing. The calzone really wasn't our thing because it was heavy on the ricotta cheese. Over all would recommend this place as long as your order is clear and you double check it. Food was definitely amazing, we love Buffalo chicken pizza and this is one of the best we have ever had! Also appreciate the following days customer service and them correcting their mistake which you don't...

My husband and I went to this place twice, both of them were ordered for pickup.

First thing I want to say, please add an option for online ordering to pay at the restaurant if we’re using cash. I like points.

Anyways,

First time everything tasted great! Good portion size (medium pizzas) and the pepperoni rolls were delicious!

The second time (08.16.2025) My husband got the same pizza from last time (meat lovers medium) he enjoyed it. I got the medium white pizza but I added spinach to it. Only to take the pizza home and realize there is BARELY any spinach on it. So kind of peeved about that. If you guys are going to charge for extras at least make it fair with the quantity. The pizza is expensive enough without adding extras. Also the mozzarella sticks, they looked like they just came from the Publix frozen section and got microwaved. Our dog enjoyed them though so you get stars from her.

I’m voting four stars because I didn’t think about taking a picture of my pizza before eating it, and overall the food is good, just upset with how little spinach was on the white pizza and the mozzarella sticks… Other than those two things the food is good, and the staff...

Cute little mom and pop pizza joint. Quaint atmosphere. Our server was so lovely and Food came out right away. We had the garlic knots with mozzarella on the side and thise knots were on point! So delicious! We also ordered the giant meatballs and they were 'ok', the marinara sauce though was very good and tasted fresh! We also got a medium half cheese and half pepperoni. The crust was amazing! My kiddos ate it up! My husband and I and a friend of ours ordered a hawaiian Sicilian pizza. Personally, I was expecting a thicker crust and it's not what we got and it wasn't cooked all the way through, so very doughy. However, my husband and friend enjoyed it, I didn't. I did ask the manager/owner about it and that is how they usually make it, they basically stack 2 crusts together, add toppings, and then cook it. So if you're ok with doughy pizza then according to my husband, it very yummy. While I enjoyed the kiddos pizza more. Owner/manager was fantastic though! He did offer to make another one and cook it more. He was very professional and friendly. So we will definitely go back! I'd love to try some of their...