Little Sicily — Restaurant in Florida

This might be a bit long. Last night I chose Little Sicily for my 70th birthday celebration We got there and the highlight of the meal was then arranging a table for 10 Awesome! I noticed only 2 servers working and I had a bad feeling. We waiting quite a bit to get our server to take our order. He looked a bit overwhelmed. But took our order. We told who was to go on what check. 4 on 1 check 2 on another and 4 on the last. We waited for food... and waited and waited. Finally 1 item came out Chicken parm sandwich...10 minutes later a stromboli and 2 slices of cheese pizza.10 minutes later another pizza came out. 10 minutes my pizza came out large green pepper mushroom and sausage it was not hot it was warm not the way I like it at all. It was cut in squares which I did appreciate. Crust not done enough. Now we are still missing chicken wings and mozza. Sticks and a eggplant parm sub. Server no where to our table to check on us. Part of my party got up to get refills on drinks. We had to go to the server to ask about our missing items. In a few minutes and girl came with a bag and asked if we had a to go order with wings and mozzarella. Yes but we are dining in she left in a bit of a huff and no mention of the missing eggplant sub. Finally in a few minutes the items minus the eggplant arrived on plates Also NOT HOT! THE eggplant never arrived and the server apologized for not putting it in the computer... At this point I wanted to just be done as this was no where how I envisioned my 70th bd dinner. We had eaten for lunch at L.S. and enjoyed it so that is why it was chosen. The bill we had to go over who got what. I thought we discussed this at the very beginning? We were never offered if we wanted dessert... No birthday singing with my grand children. We were there for like 2 - 2 1/2 hours for a pizza dinner... Nope very disappointed. Best in Lee County? Not last night.. This experience does not encourage me to travel from the Cape to dine here again in the future. SORRY... You needed more servers...

I love this guy’s pizza and have been buying it for about a year, I think it is some of the best. That being said they suffer from the same thing that sinks so many pizza shops, consistency. I worked in kitchens for over 30 years. You need to learn how to work your ovens. Hot and cold spots and proper temperature for slow and busy nights. I can hear your griping as I wright this, “I know all that.” Then why on several occasions have they been burnt? Too the point I have put in the app, please do not over cook, on several occasions. That should have been your first red flag that you have a problem. I’ll say it again consistency. Consistency is key! I was pleased to find, last night, I could order online and even happier that I could get it delivered. I tried to order a small and was told I needed approx. 6 dollars more for delivery. Disappointed I changed my order to a large and was disgusted to see I needed another 5 cents for the order. You should change that your losing business if I can’t get a large extra cheese pizza delivered. Ad 5 cents to the price. So, I settled in on a small extra cheese pizza, marinara sauce side and corn nuggets. All I wanted was the small pizza. 45 minutes and $32.00 later it arrived. The top looked great and the bottom was black. It also seemed to weigh much less than I seemed to remember. $32.00 is to much for a small pizza. Delivered including tip maybe. I’m going back to the Uber Eats app. I suggest you look at Stars Restaurant pricing and Ninos in San Carlos Park they both consistently serve the same product every time. Yes, every time. that’s...

Little Sicily 11-16-24 Stopped by with some friends around 6:30pm on a Saturday. This place was neat, clean well lit and easy to park. Our waitress Katlin came over fast and took all our drink orders. She was back fast to deliver our drinks and take our food orders. I ordered the Stromboli which had Green Pepper, Onion, Ham, Mushrooms, Pepperoni, and Sausage. I also added a house salad which had Spring Mix, Tomato, Onions, and Olives. My wife ordered an Italian Hoagie which came with Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettice, Tomato, Onion, Oil, and Vinegar. She added a Tossed Salad which had Spring Mix, Roasted red Pepper, Artichokes, Olives, Tomato, Red Onion, and Cheese. She also ordered a slice of Cheese Pizza. Our friends ordered Fettuccine Alfredo and a Pasta Primavera. Our food orders came out in reasonable time, and everything was hot. My Stromboli was fantastic and packed full of meat & Cheeses. My wife’s slice was very good, and her Hoagie was packed full of meats and lettuce and tomatoes. She said it was one of the best subs she ever had in this area. Our friends stated their Fettuccine Alfredo, and a Pasta Primavera was very good. This place was a pleasant surprise. Our waitress Kaitlin was amazing and on the ball for all our needs even the owner Joe came over to our table to make sure everything was ok. I give this place 5 out of 5 stars because of the great food, fantastic service, ice cold beer and reasonable prices. I believe you all need to try this place you will not be sorry. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Follow Me On FB For More...