Goody’s Lobster Shack — Restaurant in Frankfort

We decided to eat here after reading the reviews online and we love a good lobster roll. Unfortunately, that was not our experience today. We were quite surprised when our Connecticut style lobster roll was served ice cold with re-hardened butter.

Assuming there was a mix up I approached the window to let them know and I was told lobster rolls are always served cold...even the Connecticut style with warmed butter.

This really bothered me so I spent sometime reading online confirming that Connecticut style lobster rolls are always served hot and one recipe went as far as explaining why you can't put melted butter on cold lobster.

I hope this review helps others know what to expect when ordering here and also provides suggestions to edit the menu description to include "always...

Taking a chance on this fully outdoor food truck/tiny house was the BEST decision! The food was amazing - we got the lobster Mac & cheese and the sauteed scallops. The Mac & cheese was rich and flavorful. The addition of roasted red peppers was absolutely genius, and there were HUGE chunks of lobster meat. My friends got the scallops and said they were so tender and flavorful. We also tried the key lime pie. Tart and rich, just what key lime should be - the cinnamon graham cracker crust was a delightful surprise! Overall, just delicious, and you get a full-size restaurant portion. This is not Red Lobster food - it's actual, real homemade meals! It is expensive, and I...

I find it very strange that the towns we visited along M22 didn’t have more seafood places. We were glad to find Goody’s Lobster Shack. My son got the lobster mac and cheese. My husband got the lobster roll and I got the shrimp po boy. We all got something different so we could try each others. They did not skimp on the seafood. Large pieces in each one. I personally loved the shrimp po boy. The garlic butter and lemon aioli added the right touch and made it so good. We were also able to find a picnic table close to the water and enjoy the view as we ate our wonderful meal. The only draw back I can see is that they are not closer to...