Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop — Restaurant in Gilbert

Picture this. You come to Cream of the Crop often. At least three times a month. All the flavors are delicious but one day they come out with THE flavor. BURNT HONEY. You try this absolutely incredible flavor and then end up coming back multiple times in one week. Only to find out a couple weeks later burnt honey is gone. Surely its on rotation... I thought to myself. Surely they'll bring it back next month... No.. its been almost two years I think. AN ETERNITY. I've already had a kid since then. The kid is walking now and burnt honey is still not back. Sure, they've added some other flavors with honeycomb, but they are not THE flavor. Anywho, what does any normal person do when they're faced with this? DM the business on Instagram of course and threaten them to bring it back. However you never hear back because you're probably stuck in the requests folder that no one ever check. Don't worry I'm not mad at you for that. I've been so distraught. We still come back all the time because lets face it, the other flavors are still pretty great but each time I walk up and scan the flavor board at first glance and don't see burnt honey on there, I die a little inside. That was the case until one fateful evening when randomly after dinner on Friday night we decided to load up everyone into the car to go to Cream of the Crop and although burnt honey wasn't on there, we end up running into someone who looks like he might own the place. I stopped the poor man on his way from the bathroom after I harassed his employees about bringing the flavor back and he PROMISED me, he'll bring it back soon. So here I am, a week later writing this review just in case he forgot about our agreement to ensure he brings it back. Thank you very much for taking the time to read about my absolute love for this place and the most elite ice cream flavor there ever was....

The ice cream shop is located inside one of the Barnone structure on Agritopia Farm. You'll park outside on a dirt/gravel lot, and then from there you'll walk up and see a half-cylinder metal building. Enter in there, and in front of you, you will see the ice-cream store inside the building. Seating is a bit limited and the space is a bit small. However, don't be fooled by size. The taste of this ice-cream shop was very fresh. I also like how the ice cream wasn't overly sweet. The ice cream was fresh and just the right amount of sweet and creamy. Service was quick and friendly. Note: I would recommend going for the kids size cup vs. regular, as regular...

There’s something wonderfully unexpected about grabbing a glass of tap water at Cream of the Crop—an ice cream haven in Gilbert. From the very first sip, you notice a crisp smoothness. Perfectly chilled, it offers instant relief from Arizona’s heat, making it feel like a mini oasis alongside your sweet treat.

This refreshing water also does wonders for your palate. After each delightful scoop—whether vegan dark chocolate or starry night—a sip resets your taste buds and amplifies every nuance. By the time you finish your cone, the tap water at Cream of the Crop feels like the perfect complement to...