Eisenhower Diner
Eisenhower Diner things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
I had a conversation with the manager (Michael) and he hyped me up on trying the chipped beef and homemade real potato homefries (real potatoes 🤔 yeah right, I was suspicious most restaurant owners say this) so after work tonight I went on over around 6pm. I walk in and see 3 young kids chatting among themselves until they see me like a deer with headlights. I said just one. The one gentleman started showing me the way and asked if I wanted a booth or table. I get to my table, and after a minute or two, my server comes to me and admittedly asked if I wanted a drink. I got the house brewed sweet tea and a water. After a few moments, she came back, and I ordered the chipped beef. Unfortunately, they were out, so I got the steak and eggs. I didn't have to wait long for my meal to come out, and she asked if I wanted anything else. I asked for A1, and she came back admittedly with it and then disappeared. My steak was cooked perfectly, a bit watery but cooked perfectly. Eggs, toast, and the homefries were SLAPPING! 👌 REAL POTATOES FOR SURE! I didn't see her till it was ready for me to leave, she comes back to apologize for the wait and got me a box and my check. When I checked out, I had a gift card, and at first, they didn't know how to add it to my bill. I appreciated the teamwork amongst each other. You barely see that nowadays. Overall, my experience besides the service was amazing. I would say customer service and server etiquette would need a tad bit working on. I will be coming back for that chipped beef sometime👀👌
MelenaMelena
00
This was our second time here and it was strange. My boyfriend wanted chicken and waffles and we were pleased to see that they had that on their daily specials menu. So he ordered it. When it came out it was nothing like what he thought it was going to be. Both of us had never seen this monstrosity before and were very confused. He asked our server for clarification and stated that he thought it was going to be chicken tenders and waffles with syrup which is what the majority of people know chicken and waffles to be. Our server responded in what could seem to be a form of gaslighting, acting like we had 3 heads and came from another planet and responded with "Ew, no. This is the chicken over waffles that diners typically serve." It was left at that. Thinking that we were just not knowledgeable in diner cuisine and it was our mistake, my boyfriend still tried to eat the dish and couldn't make it through more than a quarter of the waffle. It was underseasoned, barely had chicken, and from the looks of it was just old chicken noodle soup that they thickened and threw on top of a waffle. We didn't ask for a discount and we didn't want to make a big deal out of it because honestly we just wanted to leave. We left disappointed and honestly baffled. We even googled "chicken over waffles" and 90% of the images are the chicken tenders with waffles. I suggest labeling your dishes more appropriately. I understand Hanover has an Amish community, but labeling something like "chicken over waffles" as "Amish style chicken over waffles" or "Chicken gravy over waffles" would be a better choice. Also we overheard one of your servers tell the hostess seating guests "Hey, there's guests ready to be seated and I'd prefer not to get them." Which seems like an unprofessional thing to do as a server in a resturant, especially when it was loud enough for guests to hear.
Ashley ClousAshley Clous
00
Tonight we thought we would try a new diner, the Eisenhower Diner. I had some good expectations but it failed to live up to those expectations. We were greeted by friendly hostess and seated. The menu had a good variety of items but not too many. I went with the Louisiana panini with fries. My wife had the sirloin steal. At first sight it looked good, but then I opened the sandwich to find a tiny piece of chicken and no sauce. I swear I read that it would have BBQ sauce. I asked for a side of BBQ sauce, and I'm glad I did. The sandwich was supposed to have Cajun seasoning, but I didn't taste anything remotely like Cajun, so I dipped the sandwich in the BBQ sauce. So that was a big disappointment. My wife also commented that her steak had no seasoning. The fries were really good and our son had the sweet potato fries and they were also really good. They just need to season their food better. I also wish the chicken portions were bigger. As for the restaurant it was a strange combination of decor. The orange paint color was confusing and random art work that had no theme. Really friendly staff and the place was clean. Not the worst but room for improvement, especially the seasoning.
Tim TaltonTim Talton
00
I'm really surprised that since it's opening it's been packed with people. So, apparently if the scheduled employees don't show up , is an excuse for what we encountered. The floor is a sudden down ramp, which is dangerous because it's not marked with a warning. And yes I lost my balance. The big booths are uncomfortable to say the least. And ours came with a used bloody diabetes test strip. So, next is the filthy silverware. Which looked like trash, mismatched cheap utensils. Wires hanging down from the ceiling. I ordered eggs Benedict because I was told the omelets were too large if you aren't a big eater well, look at the picture my ? Is this considered small. The food was not hot. My potatoes were overdone my husband's were fine. It looks like they spilled the sauce, not place it on the eggs, way too much sauce. It tasted fair, looked curdled and they didn't even check the plate before giving it me with broken eggshells stucked to the plate where the food was. I think they need to get more servers, and busers that take pride in a job. A new dishwasher, and please get real silverware. All in all, I definitely would not recommend Eisenhower Dinner.
Gail WaltonGail Walton
00
Update! Disappointed :( Not sure what happened this time but the ball was absolutely dropped. Basic instructions were very hard to follow, and it was not busy. Ordered a sandwich to go and asked for bread on the side... had to ask for replacement toast. Then had to ask for a box even though it was clear this was to go. My food including the togo food was all delivered but my boyfriends came to the table waayyy later. And it was wrong, he ordered an omelet with steak and there was no meat in it. The server asked to take it back explaining someone else took the omelet he ordered. He said no considering how long it took and was hungry. They still charged hi m for the omelet plus steak even though we were obviously not happy. The little things people, I asked for extra lemon which was put in the glass of water. So I had to fish out each slice to squeeze. Decent prices and the chicken salad was very good, shredded style. But I doubt I will be back any time soon. Would have been easy to take the omelet off my bill and the lady at the register could have easily asked how my service was.. but DIDNT cause she already knew!
Gabrielle HarrisonGabrielle Harrison
00
Nearby Attractions Of Eisenhower Diner
R/C Hanover Movies 16
Raymour & Flanigan Furniture and Mattress Store
Garrick Jewelers
Staples
Nerdtopia

R/C Hanover Movies 16
4.5
(829)Click for details

Raymour & Flanigan Furniture and Mattress Store
4.9
(293)Click for details

Garrick Jewelers
4.9
(132)Click for details

Staples
3.7
(94)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Eisenhower Diner
Lu Hibachi Buffet Grill
Bob's Beer & Soda
Jerry & Sal’s Pizza
New Alfredo's Pizza II & Ristorante
El Agave Market Restaurant
Texas Roadhouse
Perkins American Food Co.
Red Lobster
Chili's Grill & Bar
The Best Wok

Lu Hibachi Buffet Grill
4.0
(988)Click for details

Bob's Beer & Soda
4.8
(246)Click for details

Jerry & Sal’s Pizza
4.2
(278)Click for details

New Alfredo's Pizza II & Ristorante
4.4
(204)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
375 Eisenhower Dr, Hanover, PA 17331
Map
Phone
(717) 634-5675
Call
Website
facebook.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.1
(557 reviews)
Ratings & Description
attractions: R/C Hanover Movies 16, Raymour & Flanigan Furniture and Mattress Store, Garrick Jewelers, Staples, Nerdtopia, restaurants: Lu Hibachi Buffet Grill, Bob's Beer & Soda, Jerry & Sal’s Pizza, New Alfredo's Pizza II & Ristorante, El Agave Market Restaurant, Texas Roadhouse, Perkins American Food Co., Red Lobster, Chili's Grill & Bar, The Best Wok
