Four Sisters Bakery & Catering — Restaurant in Hawaii

Four Sisters was recommended by several well traveled friends, some of whom also recommended we arrive at opening time to avoid the line. They open at 5am. I love carbs, but I am not getting up at the crack of dawn for carbs. We arrived a little before 9am on a Friday and there were a few people in front of us, but luckily no heinous line.

We ordered their wildly popular butter rolls, and people aren't exaggerating. They are very delicious. So simple, so understated, so puffy, so yummy! The buttery ball of goodness has an extra golden glaze on the bottom. They're also so perfectly puffed up that it is completely hollow inside. We seemed to have been the only ones that just wanted a taste. Most of the other patrons were ordering them by the dozen.

They also offer a bunch of other delicious baked goods, like banana bread, mango bread, red bean buns, cinnamon buns, and they cater events. Gosh, what don't they do?

I've never heard of mango bread before, so I was curious to try a loaf. We were leaving for the airport soon, so I ended up taking the mango bread on the flight and didn't crack it open until we were back home. If it weren't for the label I wouldn't have known it was mango bread as the mango flavor wasn't that strong. However, it was sweet and stayed moist throughout hours of travel time.

To this day, I still remember how good the butter rolls...

We had Four Sisters cater our wedding as we wanted traditional Filipino food and were beyond disappointed. We picked our food up from the bakery with the best intentions leaving a good tip and driving straight to the reception venue. When we arrived we opened the food and were honestly disgusted. There were 5 fried FLIES in with our fried lumpia -- which we did not end up serving. Beyond that the ribs and adobo were not pleasant looking and the remainder of the food tasted extremely bland. We had several guests become sick the next day. When the owner was contacted about is she agreed it was unacceptable, but then proceeded to say that we are probably mistaken and the "flies" were most likely the tips of lumpia. I proceeded to send her the pictures we had taken of the flies in the tray with the lumpia. Having received no reply from her since, I am assuming there will be no refund. I would not recommend the catering...

We stopped into Four Sisters Bakery in Maui just to try their famous butter rolls—and wow, they did not disappoint! The rolls were unbelievably soft, gooey, and drenched in sweet, buttery goodness. We ordered three so we could really get a fair taste, and every bite was amazing. Honestly, some of the best rolls we’ve ever had.

We didn’t try anything else on this visit (though everything in the case looked tempting), because the butter rolls were exactly what we came for. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better.

I’ll definitely be back again—next time I might branch out, but I can tell you right now, I’d go back just for those butter...