Caplinger's Fresh Catch — Restaurant in Indianapolis

The oyster po-boy was superb. Absolutely amazing so much fresh oyster, lettuce, fresh onions, a perfect remoulade to go with it on a perfect hoagie. And the crab cakes are to die for, best all around. The clam chowder is next level. I don't know how to describe it other than it tastes better than you can possibly imagine. It's my favorite thing I had today. It reminded me of old memories. Yours is the absolute best recipe and it's better than my own recipe my family makes. Everything was thoroughly made and seasoned to perfection. And acute attention to detail on everything. The condiments are Monarch. Everything at this market is so fresh and it's like stepping into a whole different state, one that is coastal with all of these options. The menu is extensive and the quality is unparalleled. The service was amazing and the staff were super friendly and nice. They also offer their own teas which are the perfect pairing with this delicious variety of seafood. This place is as fabulous of a market as it is a restaurant. I will definitely be back, thank you guys for one of the best experiences I've had. P.S. as you can tell the...

Had lunch at the South side location. I was a bit surprised by the building, I was expecting something a bit more modern. Order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. Get your own fountain drinks, but they do have bottles. I had a tenderloin (don’t like fish), red beans/rice and collard greens. I loved the tenderloin. It was thick with just the right amount of breading and piping hot served on a soft grilled bun. Really, really good sandwich. Sides were tasty and served hot. My companion had the Caplinger’s special sandwich, lobster bisque soup and baked beans. Sandwich was excellent but she raved over the soup. Restaurant/store was very clean and the staff was friendly, helpful and efficient. Will definitely be back. Sorry, no pictures. We dug right in and ate every...

Ordered dine in, and sat at a table right in front of the cash counter. 45 minutes later we had to ask, to find out our food was given to someone else. There was no mention or attempt to "make it right". Not that we want freebies, but the courtesy goes a long way. We always let things happen naturally and dont make a scene, so we can objectively decide if we will return or not. We will absolutely be sticking with the Greenwood location from now on. I had the Lobster Roll, that was dry with the texture and flavor of imitation crab. Can't think of a time I have had lobster that was stringy. With having such great experiences with the Greenwood location, we were greatly let down on this visit to...