HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis — Restaurant in Indianapolis

Name
Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis
Description
Small, counter-serve spot serving thin-crust pizzas, wings & rib tips in a no-frills space.
Nearby attractions
Atomic Bowl Duckpin
1105 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Fountain Square Theatre
1111 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, United States
LO-FI Lounge
G. C. Murphy Building, 1043 Virginia Ave #215, Indianapolis, IN 46203
The Murphy Art Center
1043 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Czerny Gardens
1331 Wright St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Idle Park
800 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Hot Shot Tot Lot
Grove Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Stacy Park
1503 Hoyt Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Nearby restaurants
ON THE ROCKS MEXICAN KITCHEN
1140 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
The Brass Ring Lounge
1245 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Super Tortas Lucha Libre
1261 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Kuma's Corner
1127 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
El Arado Mexican Grill
1063 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar
1103 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Upland FSQ Brewery
1201 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Revolucion
1132 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
magdalena
1127 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Red Lion Grog House
1043 Virginia Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Nearby hotels
Fountainview Inn
1105 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, United States
Related posts
Keywords
Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis tourism.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis hotels.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis bed and breakfast. flights to Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis attractions.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis restaurants.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis travel.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis travel guide.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis travel blog.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis pictures.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis photos.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis travel tips.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis maps.Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis things to do.
Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis
United StatesIndianaIndianapolisPapa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis

Basic Info

Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis

1267 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
3.6(524)
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Small, counter-serve spot serving thin-crust pizzas, wings & rib tips in a no-frills space.

attractions: Atomic Bowl Duckpin, Fountain Square Theatre, LO-FI Lounge, The Murphy Art Center, Czerny Gardens, Idle Park, Hot Shot Tot Lot, Stacy Park, restaurants: ON THE ROCKS MEXICAN KITCHEN, The Brass Ring Lounge, Super Tortas Lucha Libre, Kuma's Corner, El Arado Mexican Grill, Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar, Upland FSQ Brewery, Revolucion, magdalena, Red Lion Grog House
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(317) 820-3173
Website
paparayspizza.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Indianapolis
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Indianapolis
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Indianapolis
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Chicken Gyro With Fries
dish
Falafel Gyro With Fries
dish
Lamb Gyro With Fries
dish
BBQ Chicken Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Meat- Atarian Pizza Small 10"
dish
Meat- Atarian Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza Large 14"
dish
Vegetarian Pizza Small 10"
dish
Meat- Atarian Pizza Large 14"
dish
Meat- Atarian Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Greek Pizza Large 14"
dish
Italian Sausage Pizza Large 14"
dish
BBQ Chicken Pizza Large 14"
dish
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Small 10"
dish
Vegetarian Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza 16"
dish
Italian Sausage Pizza Small 10"
dish
Greek Pizza Small 10"
dish
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Vegetarian Pizza Large 14"
dish
Greek Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Italian Sausage Pizza Medium 12"
dish
The Works Pizza Small 10"
dish
Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza Small 10"
dish
Greek Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
BBQ Chicken Pizza Small 10"
dish
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Large 14"
dish
Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza Medium 12"
dish
BBQ Chicken Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Italian Sausage Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Vegetarian Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Cheese Pizza Small 10"
dish
Cheese Pizza Extra Large 16"
dish
Cheese Pizza Large 14"
dish
Cheese Pizza Medium 12"
dish
Italian Sausage Calzone Wrap
dish
The Works Calzone Wrap
dish
Parmesan Garlic Bread
dish
Seasoned Fries
dish
Cheesy Garlic Bread
dish
Bosco Bread Sticks
dish
Ray's Fries
dish
Garlic Knots
dish
Monster Chocolate Cake
dish
25 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
50 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
35 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
15 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
7 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
100 Pieces Boneless Wings
dish
Papa Ray's House Salad
dish
Mostaccioli W/Marinara
dish
Mostaccioli W/Marinara, Sausage & Peppers
dish
Baked Mostaccioli W/Mozzarella

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis

Atomic Bowl Duckpin

Fountain Square Theatre

LO-FI Lounge

The Murphy Art Center

Czerny Gardens

Idle Park

Hot Shot Tot Lot

Stacy Park

Atomic Bowl Duckpin

Atomic Bowl Duckpin

4.5

(374)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Fountain Square Theatre

Fountain Square Theatre

4.6

(173)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
LO-FI Lounge

LO-FI Lounge

4.5

(39)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
The Murphy Art Center

The Murphy Art Center

4.9

(9)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Craft an epoxy charcuterie board woodworking class
Craft an epoxy charcuterie board woodworking class
Fri, Dec 12 • 6:00 PM
Brownsburg, Indiana, 46112
View details
Candlelight: Tribute to Coldplay
Candlelight: Tribute to Coldplay
Thu, Dec 11 • 6:30 PM
650 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, 46204
View details
Create pottery in a private studio
Create pottery in a private studio
Sat, Dec 13 • 7:00 PM
Indianapolis, Indiana, 46203
View details

Nearby restaurants of Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis

ON THE ROCKS MEXICAN KITCHEN

The Brass Ring Lounge

Super Tortas Lucha Libre

Kuma's Corner

El Arado Mexican Grill

Maialina Italian Kitchen + Bar

Upland FSQ Brewery

Revolucion

magdalena

Red Lion Grog House

ON THE ROCKS MEXICAN KITCHEN

ON THE ROCKS MEXICAN KITCHEN

5.0

(2)

Click for details
The Brass Ring Lounge

The Brass Ring Lounge

4.3

(271)

Click for details
Super Tortas Lucha Libre

Super Tortas Lucha Libre

4.9

(63)

Click for details
Kuma's Corner

Kuma's Corner

4.6

(1.8K)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

Ā© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings Indianapolis

3.6
(524)
avatar
1.0
6y

I have heard some good things about Papa Ray's so we thought we would give it a try and order from Uber Eats Last night. Our order was delivered by Uber in about 35min. We were off a a good start! Then, we opened the box and discovered that we had an incorrect order. We called the store at 7:05. and a very hasty woman put me on hold three times and then came back on the line and took my address and phone number and told me they would resend a correct order to us using their drivers and I could expect my order in about 25min. At 9:00 PM, we had not received our order so I called back and spoke to the same woman. After putting me on hold several times, a driver got on the line and told me that he had delivered it. He had left it inside the door on a table. I told him, I was sorry, but have been home the entire evening and that I could assure him that he did not come into my home and leave a pizza on my table. (Wow) He then asked me if I lived at the halfway house because the did in fact deliver it. I laughed and told him, no I did not live in a halfway house. At this point the hasty woman got back on the phone and yelled at me for giving her the wrong address and was insinuating that it was my fault for giving her the wrong address. I tried to explain to her that I am quite sure of my address, but she insisted it was my fault. Regardless, she told me she would remake the pizza again and have it to me in 25min. At 10:00pm, I still had not received my order so I called back again and politely asked to speak to a manager. The hasty woman said he was outside. I asked if I could hold for him and she told me no. So I attempted to ask her where my pizza was that she promised would be there in 25min. I again was put on hold and when she returned she said she was too busy to have my order delivered to me. I could not believe what she was saying. I asked her why she told me it was going to be delivered in 25min then. She at that point hung up on me and would not answer my phone calls. I contacted Uber and they refunded my money, but can I just say I cannot believe that after three hours of being told my order was on its way, she just make the decision to not worry about it. I called the store this morning and asked to speak to the manager and was told there was no manager available. I left a message to have someone return my call. We will see if...

Ā Ā Ā Read more
avatar
1.0
47w

I order the works casond cheesy garlic bread on January 7 @ 10:03 pm was told via text that it was on the way and two hours later it was delivered to a corner table at the hospital not where it was supposed to be. The casone dough was not cooked on the I side. The cheesy garlic bread has no sauce on it and both were very cold. The outside of the box was covered in motor oil and smelled horrible. Called store to be told that the first delivery the driver broke down and that it had to be remade. It was as cold as it was outside. They acted like it was no big deal there was motor oil on the box. But said I would get a refund. When I called to complain today the woman on the phone just wanted to argue and wouldn't let me tell her what happened. She just said I would have to go through GrubHub to get a refund and that no one there told her they would refund my money when they did. I have text message of where the food was put, at a desk in the back corner of the entrance to the hospital where I work. So at midnight I had paid for food that wasn't able to be eaten and this company acted like it wasn't a big deal. Please be careful what you order from there. They obviously don't care what they .make or do t make for their customers. I could have died from injesting motor oil. Never once did the store say they were sorry when I called the next and acted rude, unprofessional and like I was trying to not pay for my food. Please watch what you purchased and what the box is soaked in. This place needs to think about their customers and not treat them horrible when you called to find out why my order was covered in motor oil. So if you want two hour late pizza that is very cold and the box covered in oil I would scroll past this place and order from anyone else. I do have pictures of all...

Ā Ā Ā Read more
avatar
1.0
2y

On July 5th, we ordered dinner from this pizza restaurant for 3 adults and 4 kids. The total came out to $74 including 3 pizzas, boneless chicken wings and tiramisu dessert. We placed the order by phone and paid by credit card. Almost 20 minutes after we placed the order, we got a call back from the restaurant stating they would not be able to fulfil our order because they were out of tiramisu and chicken wings. We told them to forget it and we canceled the order in full with a full refund to the credit card.

When I got home from my trip, I called the credit card company on Friday July 7 and asked about this transaction. We were told to contact the restaurant directly and try to resolve the charge. I called the restaurant that weekend and explained what happened. I was told by a woman on the phone to call back on Monday and talk to the owner. On Monday I was told to call the owner Atif directly. So I called him on Monday evening and told him about my fraudulent charge for an order we had canceled. He said he’d look into it and call me back by Thursday. I called him back in thursday afternoon for an update. He did not answer. I called the restaurant and the same woman told me she didn’t know why he didn’t answer and hung up on me. I was getting frustrated with being given the run around but I was not about to accept being on the hook for a clearly FRAUDULENT charge for goods that we didn’t receive and an order that we canceled. I called Atif back 3 more times over the course of Thursday evening and also sent him a text. This was as of July 13. On July 14 I proceeded to call my credit card company and file a complaint to dispute this...

Ā Ā Ā Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Caitlin BottiglierieCaitlin Bottiglierie
Let me start out, I'm not one to complain, especially not one to make a public review, but I couldn't help myself this time. This is the first time that I have ever been here. I placed an online order, and calzones are my favorite. First thing I've actually craved in my pregnancy... so it's after midnight the night of my birthday (tonight), and I wanted a calzone so bad, I come across pictures of Papa rays calzones on Google. Decided to order one, didn't read reviews... well, I should have. This was the worst experience I've ever had!!! Lady was rude with an attitude that was not welcoming at all when I went in to pick up and pay for my food. I get home in excitement. Outside of the calzone was golden brown, and it smelled amazing, so i ate a few bites and noticed that the whole inside was raw dough... not slightly raw, completely raw, the whole inside. So I called to complain, and the same lady was rude and insisted I come back and get it replaced. I'm definitely not getting back out, and I definitely don't want to get another raw dough calzone. So I had to insist on a refund, which should have been an option from the beginning. I'd suggest yall just stay home and cook or eat leftovers like I should have done.
shemata chatmanshemata chatman
I wouldn’t trust this place. They probably do cook food but you should watch them because they also steal credit cards and information. I did order from a third-party app however, it’s not the app that was the problem. It’s the merchant who failed to deliver my food and tried to blame my neighbors for stealing it and my neighbors do not eat pizza. It’s not in their normal diet. I reached out to the merchant who didn’t even no by my information who I was. She was so rude and dry didn’t care it’s 123 in the morning. I understand that it’s late in the morning and you may even be tired, but can you imagine that I could be a customer who’s tired from work as well and waiting on my food. Scratch that I have to go to White Castle who seemingly have way better customer service. This place was rude. My worst nightmare didn’t offer me solution hung up on me so many times stop answering my phone calls when I just was trying to find solutions mind you the app is telling me to reach out to the merchant because the papa rays has signed up to deliver their own food. The pizzas are very small and I bet they probably don’t even taste good they’ve lost a customer for life!
Ivan SleetIvan Sleet
This was a mid night stumble across Mom & pops joint in Fountain Square. The place was empty when we entered. What seemed to be a woman and her daughter were frantically working on an iPad and a computer register, I guess trying to figure things out. We were not even slightly acknowledged until maybe a minute or so after standing in front of the counter. I asked if we could dine in, to which the reply was yes. We seated ourselves at a table. There was no menu and obviously no waitress or waiter service. I had to get a menu from another table. Then I had to go to the counter again to place my order. Long story short, the customer service was non existent. To me this makes or breaks an establishment. They can have long wait times and mediocre food and drinks, and if the customer service is great….yep they’ll receive a 5 ā­ļøfrom me every time. The food industry is a RELATIONSHIP based industry. How you make people feel when they come to spend their hard earned money with YOU. (We felt unwelcome!) THE ONLY REASON I’m giving this a 3 ā­ļø is because the food was hot, definitely freshly made, and uniquely flavored. I’m outāœŒšŸ¾šŸ¤Ø
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Indianapolis

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Let me start out, I'm not one to complain, especially not one to make a public review, but I couldn't help myself this time. This is the first time that I have ever been here. I placed an online order, and calzones are my favorite. First thing I've actually craved in my pregnancy... so it's after midnight the night of my birthday (tonight), and I wanted a calzone so bad, I come across pictures of Papa rays calzones on Google. Decided to order one, didn't read reviews... well, I should have. This was the worst experience I've ever had!!! Lady was rude with an attitude that was not welcoming at all when I went in to pick up and pay for my food. I get home in excitement. Outside of the calzone was golden brown, and it smelled amazing, so i ate a few bites and noticed that the whole inside was raw dough... not slightly raw, completely raw, the whole inside. So I called to complain, and the same lady was rude and insisted I come back and get it replaced. I'm definitely not getting back out, and I definitely don't want to get another raw dough calzone. So I had to insist on a refund, which should have been an option from the beginning. I'd suggest yall just stay home and cook or eat leftovers like I should have done.
Caitlin Bottiglierie

Caitlin Bottiglierie

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Indianapolis

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
I wouldn’t trust this place. They probably do cook food but you should watch them because they also steal credit cards and information. I did order from a third-party app however, it’s not the app that was the problem. It’s the merchant who failed to deliver my food and tried to blame my neighbors for stealing it and my neighbors do not eat pizza. It’s not in their normal diet. I reached out to the merchant who didn’t even no by my information who I was. She was so rude and dry didn’t care it’s 123 in the morning. I understand that it’s late in the morning and you may even be tired, but can you imagine that I could be a customer who’s tired from work as well and waiting on my food. Scratch that I have to go to White Castle who seemingly have way better customer service. This place was rude. My worst nightmare didn’t offer me solution hung up on me so many times stop answering my phone calls when I just was trying to find solutions mind you the app is telling me to reach out to the merchant because the papa rays has signed up to deliver their own food. The pizzas are very small and I bet they probably don’t even taste good they’ve lost a customer for life!
shemata chatman

shemata chatman

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Indianapolis

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

This was a mid night stumble across Mom & pops joint in Fountain Square. The place was empty when we entered. What seemed to be a woman and her daughter were frantically working on an iPad and a computer register, I guess trying to figure things out. We were not even slightly acknowledged until maybe a minute or so after standing in front of the counter. I asked if we could dine in, to which the reply was yes. We seated ourselves at a table. There was no menu and obviously no waitress or waiter service. I had to get a menu from another table. Then I had to go to the counter again to place my order. Long story short, the customer service was non existent. To me this makes or breaks an establishment. They can have long wait times and mediocre food and drinks, and if the customer service is great….yep they’ll receive a 5 ā­ļøfrom me every time. The food industry is a RELATIONSHIP based industry. How you make people feel when they come to spend their hard earned money with YOU. (We felt unwelcome!) THE ONLY REASON I’m giving this a 3 ā­ļø is because the food was hot, definitely freshly made, and uniquely flavored. I’m outāœŒšŸ¾šŸ¤Ø
Ivan Sleet

Ivan Sleet

See more posts
See more posts