Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street — Restaurant in Lexington

I've visited this establishment twice... First experience🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 was amazing pizza was quick to come out and we got a breadstick to snack on while we ate. Connoli was amazing as well!!!! Second round 🌟🌟was partially our own fault fur going on a Friday night! It was packed but the pizza is well worth the wait!!! So we stood in line for35 minutes to order... We ordered a small pizza and a breadstick they said the pizza would be easy in 20 minutes. Went outside and waited on a table to open i have them 30 bc i knew how busy they were. When i errant back in They acted as if they were fully unaware of our order and didnt believe me (the guy who took our order want there at that moment) finally the boy who had have me my breadstick remembered Me! They checked back and low and behold i had already ordered and paid!!!! So they rush making our pizza i assume it took about 15 min n it was out!! They did try to make up for it which is why it's not a 1 star. They gave us two slices and a bread stick by the tone our pizza came tho we didn't really want it Lol..... But they have the best ranch ever 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Pizza is amazing Go during the day best...

My wife and I dropped into Lexington for a short visit. Our first night was during Lexington's "Thursday Night Live" on a closed-off down-town street with live music and food trucks. What do we see? Folks everywhere with Goodfellas Pizza boxes, eating and listening to the music. Told my wife, "I want that for dinner tomorrow."

Next day we walked to their location. There is limited seating outside, just a couple of tables, but most everyone gets it by the slice to go. (I also noticed Goodfellas makes their own crust.)

We ordered a 16" pizza. We were told, "about 25 minutes" so I set the timer on my iPhone, found a nearby bar, the Rosebud, and waited it out. (Downtown Lex is nice like that, plenty of bars).

Picked up our pizza, hot and fresh, walked it to our nearby Airbnb and had some great New York style pie. Man it was good, with plenty leftover for breakfast the next morning.

If you want pizza in the Lex, this is the...

7 p.m. on a Thursday, short line, no TNL going on. When I got to the counter there was a partial pepperoni and 4 slices left of a cheese pizza, no other choices. I asked the woman if there was any mushroom pizza or any other types. She said she had no idea, it was that busy. She was 4 feet from the oven so I asked if she could peek or ask one of the 5 men working there if there was any other types coming out soon. Another pepperoni came out so I said, okay, let's just go with a slice of cheese. She reached for a box, I said, no box please, she spun the 4 slices left, which were miss-cut and gave me the smallest, miss-cut slice. I said, "oh, you're giving me the small one" and she tossed it into the box, walked to the register and said, I don't like your attitude, I'm finding you very passive aggressive. ??? I went back to get her name after I stood outside to eat the slice...she was gone, sent to the back where...