Sir Pizza of Kentucky — Restaurant in Lexington

This has been a favorite most of my life. I am 47. Last night we stopped ordered a to go order. Got the royal feast large deal with cheese sticks. Asked for no mushrooms on my pizza. Also ordered a chicken sandwich for my daughter.

So all of a sudden the man said they don’t do military discounts and he doesn’t know what I’m talking about and we’ve always gotten one there. Offers me a free 2 liter. So I said ok cool. #1 the pizza was covered in mushrooms and I couldn’t eat the pizza. #2 the cheesesticks weren’t even cut into sticks. The dough was old or hard. Taste nasty #3 the 2 liter was outdated and had mold specks growing on the top of it on the outside of the bottle, makes no sense because the bottle was cold from the fridge. #4 chicken sandwich was saturated with some sort of extra salty substance.

I live in Nicholasville and drove all the way to this store because it’s the closest to me. Not happy. I will Not eat at this location ever again. I have questions regarding the cleanliness and sanitation due to mold on the 2 liter and the fact the man at the store was not wearing gloves and going back from taking money answering phones then preparing food. The regular people that usually run the store that I’ve seen in the past were not there. Definitely think twice before eating at this location!

I spent $41 and I’m diabetic and didn’t get to eat the ordered food thanks...

I have been coming here for 25 years and the pizza is always delicious and the same guy has been taking my order with a smile for all of those years. We always get the Royal Feast, and it is always loaded with toppings, smoking hot out of the oven, and delicious. I would always recommend eating your pizza there instead of getting it to go. When you get it to go, it steams in the box taking away the crunch of the crust. Don’t get me wrong, it is still good, but nothing like it is fresh from the oven. We have tried all of the other Sir Pizzas in Lexington and none of them taste the same as this location. I wander if they use different ovens or something at the other locations. The only draw back to eating here, is that nothing has been updated in years. As a matter of fact, I have not seen any changes in the entire 25 years that I have been coming here. This place looks like it is straight from the 70’s. My family always jokes that we are rolling the dice with food poisoning every time that we come here, but in fairness we have never had any issues in all the time we have been coming. If you want a fat unique pizza for a reasonable amount of money and you can look past the decor, I would say definitely give this place a try! Pro tip - they always run an unadvertised special where you can get any extra large pizza for the price of a large. All you have to do is ask...

I love, love, love this place! I have been a customer for almost my entire life. My mom took us there when we were kids, and it was so cool because you could place your order from the table! To explain, every table had a landline phone installed! Years later, my live for Sir Pizza continued, when I turned 16, I worked as a delivery driver, and on weekends over the summer and by college, I would meet my friends at Tony's arcade and then partake in a pitcher and 🍕. This would continue of course I would choose Sir Pizza for lunch and Pizza Nights. Later when I had to move for my job, I would be sure to visit my favorite Pizza Our place, whenever in Lexington.

Yes, the food is that fantastic so 5 stars for the food!

The service however is not the same, the super friendly people are gone replaced with people who make a good pizza, but don't seem too happy to serve it. So my review is strictly about the food, it still tastes just like it used too 45 years ago, and that is impressive!

While I am sure that their carryout and delivery business is strong, the dining room is just empty..and that place used to always be packed.

The original owner moved to Michigan and opened fine dining establishments to that serves...you guessed it, pizza, among other things! I will always be a customer, because this place is...