Your Pizza Stop — Restaurant in Menifee

I'm so bummed to stop going here. Close to home and I have spent 100's of dollars here in food the last few years, but I have to give the business a poor review. As a long standing and local customer, also a Realtor in our area, I just can no longer recommend this place. 1st issue, tried to place a pickup order late one day, and during the call the time went from 759 to past 8pm and they said can't make that order, cuz we are closing. I even said sorry and that I frequent the place so much, I figured it'd be worth a minute or 2. Nope. Then today I decided to give them another shot, because honestly I miss the food. I called to place my normal order. Medium Buffalo pizza or Medium BBQ chicken and they said "sorry need to order more stuff for delivery" I said, did your prices change? Because I've ordered the same thing countless times..hundreds of dollars worth of pizza and she said No change, our policy is 20 bucks or more BEFORE delivery fee..and I was hoping for some sort of exception, but No once again losing out on a $17 dollar pizza over 3 dollars...seems odd Math. Not to mention they asked for my address and can see I'm about 5 to 8 minutes away if that. I know gas is expensive, but I would imagine the math makes more sense to keep a customer that spends hundreds instead of losing a customer over $3.00. I gave you the 4 stars to respect your food, but the rest is...

I agree with the reviewers that say Your Pizza Stop is the best pizza place in the area, and by area I mean neighboring cities. Not claiming I have tried them all, but surely enough have spent decent money buying from more than a few. Yes, 7 years ago I rated this same place 3 Stars. Today 4 Stars, which makes them above average. The Staff, a female pizza maker and a young fellow named Ryan, were as pleasant and cool as if the heat wave that has been assailing the good people of the Inland Empire (what a name indeed) did not seemed to diminish their abilities to deliver an above average serving: Chef Salad, $7.99? A shockingly well made salad that had the recipient forget most of her manners and truly happy with the results. 4 Stars! Pizza make your own, $31+, thin crust X Large, several toppings well handled, making a good eater like me want an encore! 4 Stars! The place as unassuming as it was has put to shame most pizzerias around, and all it took is attention to detail, a positively great attitude, and nice skills building the salad and pizza. I bow with satisfaction and wish them nothing short of the best, as it is obvious they deserve...

My First Time Ordering from 'Your Pizza Stop' was a Very Good Experience!

Ordered online in advance for a pick up order of an extra large Supreme pizza, an Italian sub sandwich, and an Anti Pasta Salad. The online ordering was easy and effective.

I liked that we were given a time range when the order would be ready to pick up. When I arrived I was a little early and had to wait a few minutes for the pizza to be finished.

The public area inside is very small. Social distancing between strangers can only be for 2 people at a time by each standing at the far opposite end of the space. If you are the 3rd you might step in to give your name and then wait outside the door to have them signal you.

There was plenty of nearby parking.

I ordered Anchovies as an extra topping and was disappointed that they did not put more of the little fish on. Otherwise, all the food [Pizza, Italian Sub, & Anti Pasta Salad] was very good and enjoyed by everyone.

Thank You! to 'Your Pizza Stop' for a very tasty dinner [and left over Pizza...